The Hall of Consensus

The Hall of Consensus shows which players are supported by many sources for the Hall of Fame. These sources include the National Baseball Hall of Fame, the Hall of Stats, Baseball Think Factory’s Hall of Merit, and various Personal Halls of Fame.

There are 165 players who are in the Hall of Fame, Hall of Stats, and Hall of Merit.

Note: This first table only considers if someone was inducted as a player. The Negro Leagues table considers Hall of Famers of any classification.

Name (Hall Rating) HOF HOS HOM
Totals 240 240 280
Babe Ruth (399) true true true
Barry Bonds (363) false true true
Walter Johnson (337) true true true
Willie Mays (335) true true true
Cy Young (324) true true true
Ty Cobb (320) true true true
Henry Aaron (298) true true true
Roger Clemens (292) false true true
Rogers Hornsby (289) true true true
Honus Wagner (284) true true true
Tris Speaker (282) true true true
Ted Williams (276) true true true
Stan Musial (264) true true true
Eddie Collins (254) true true true
Pete Alexander (248) true true true
Alex Rodriguez (245) false true true
Lou Gehrig (243) true true true
Mickey Mantle (239) true true true
Lefty Grove (238) true true true
Mel Ott (233) true true true
Rickey Henderson (232) true true true
Kid Nichols (232) true true true
Mike Schmidt (228) true true true
Nap Lajoie (226) true true true
Christy Mathewson (222) true true true
Greg Maddux (220) true true true
Tom Seaver (219) true true true
Randy Johnson (217) true true true
Cap Anson (215) true true true
Frank Robinson (212) true true true
Joe Morgan (203) true true true
Jimmie Foxx (194) true true true
Eddie Mathews (191) true true true
Roberto Clemente (190) true true true
Bert Blyleven (189) true true true
Cal Ripken Jr. (188) true true true
Pedro Martinez (187) true true true
Al Kaline (187) true true true
Wade Boggs (187) true true true
Phil Niekro (186) true true true
Roger Connor (185) true true true
Carl Yastrzemski (185) true true true
Johnny Bench (181) true true true
Dan Brouthers (181) true true true
George Brett (180) true true true
Warren Spahn (176) true true true
Ken Griffey Jr. (173) true true true
Gaylord Perry (172) true true true
Curt Schilling (172) false true true
Eddie Plank (171) true true true
Chipper Jones (170) true true true
Bob Gibson (169) true true true
Joe DiMaggio (169) true true true
Charlie Gehringer (168) true true true
George Davis (167) true true true
Gary Carter (167) true true true
Steve Carlton (166) true true true
Jeff Bagwell (165) true true true
Mike Mussina (164) true true true
Arky Vaughan (163) true true true
Carlton Fisk (158) true true true
Rod Carew (157) true true true
Robin Roberts (156) true true true
Fergie Jenkins (155) true true true
Ivan Rodriguez (154) true true true
Luke Appling (152) true true true
Larry Walker (152) true true true
Pete Rose (150) false false true
Ed Delahanty (149) true true true
Brooks Robinson (148) true true true
Tom Glavine (148) true true true
Ozzie Smith (148) true true true
Mike Piazza (148) true true true
Reggie Jackson (145) true true true
Bobby Wallace (145) true true true
Nolan Ryan (145) true true true
Lou Whitaker (144) false true true
Bill Dahlen (144) false true true
Barry Larkin (144) true true true
Robin Yount (144) true true true
Alan Trammell (143) true true true
Johnny Mize (143) true true true
Scott Rolen (142) false true true
Paul Waner (142) true true true
Paul Molitor (141) true true true
Bobby Grich (140) false true true
Tim Keefe (140) true true true
Frankie Frisch (140) true true true
Frank Thomas (140) true true true
Ron Santo (139) true true true
Roy Halladay (138) true true true
Harry Heilmann (137) true true true
Kevin Brown (137) false true true
Carl Hubbell (137) true true true
Jim Thome (137) true true true
Yogi Berra (136) true true true
John Smoltz (136) true true true
Rick Reuschel (136) false true true
Edgar Martinez (135) true true true
Sam Crawford (135) true true true
Ed Walsh (134) true true true
Jackie Robinson (134) true true true
Lou Boudreau (133) true true true
Kenny Lofton (133) false true true
Billy Hamilton (131) true true true
Jack Glasscock (131) false true true
John Clarkson (131) true true true
Ryne Sandberg (130) true true true
Mariano Rivera (130) true true true
Manny Ramirez (130) false true true
Al Simmons (130) true true true
Shoeless Joe Jackson (129) false false true
Bill Dickey (129) true true true
Tim Raines (129) true true true
Dazzy Vance (129) true true true
Bob Feller (129) true true true
Duke Snider (129) true true true
Gabby Hartnett (129) true true true
Ernie Banks (129) true true true
Luis Tiant (129) false true true
Fred Clarke (128) true true true
David Cone (128) false true true
Tony Gwynn (128) true true true
Craig Biggio (128) true true true
Derek Jeter (127) true true true
Stan Coveleski (127) true true true
Hal Newhouser (127) true true true
Andruw Jones (127) false true true
Roberto Alomar (126) true true true
Willie McCovey (126) true true true
Graig Nettles (126) false true true
Reggie Smith (126) false true true
Rafael Palmeiro (125) false true true
Jim Palmer (125) true true true
Pee Wee Reese (125) true true true
Larry Doby (125) true true true
Eddie Murray (125) true true true
Willie Randolph (124) false true true
Buddy Bell (124) false true false
Mark McGwire (124) false true true
Vic Willis (124) true true false
Ted Lyons (124) true true true
Dwight Evans (124) false true true
Home Run Baker (123) true true true
Dennis Eckersley (123) true true true
Andre Dawson (123) true true true
Joe Cronin (121) true true true
Jim Edmonds (121) false true true
Bret Saberhagen (121) false true true
Todd Helton (121) false true true
Mordecai Brown (120) true true true
Richie Ashburn (120) true true true
Jim Bunning (120) true true true
Clark Griffith (120) false true true
Rube Waddell (118) true true true
Red Faber (118) true true true
Amos Rusie (117) true true true
Sal Bando (117) false true false
Ken Boyer (117) false true true
Sammy Sosa (117) false true true
Joe McGinnity (117) true true true
Goose Goslin (116) true true true
Old Hoss Radbourn (116) true true true
Gary Sheffield (116) false true true
Buck Ewing (116) true true true
Dick Allen (116) false true true
Keith Hernandez (116) false true true
Don Drysdale (115) true true true
Juan Marichal (115) true true true
Dave Winfield (114) true true true
Deacon White (114) true true true
Dave Stieb (114) false true true
Joe Gordon (114) true true true
Jesse Burkett (113) true true true
Ted Simmons (113) true true true
Harmon Killebrew (112) true true true
George Sisler (112) true true true
Bill Terry (112) true true true
Sherry Magee (112) false true true
Hank Greenberg (112) true true true
Joe Torre (112) false true true
Kevin Appier (112) false true false
Mickey Cochrane (112) true true true
Bobby Bonds (112) false true false
Minnie Miñoso (111) true true true
Vladimir Guerrero (111) true true true
Billy Williams (111) true true true
Don Sutton (111) true true true
Tony Mullane (111) false true false
Babe Adams (111) false true false
Wes Ferrell (110) false true true
Bobby Abreu (110) false true true
Jack Quinn (110) false true false
Jake Beckley (110) true true true
Jim Wynn (110) false true true
Chet Lemon (110) false true false
King Kelly (109) true true true
Urban Shocker (109) false true false
Pud Galvin (109) true true true
Zack Wheat (108) true true true
Johan Santana (108) false true true
Jim O'Rourke (108) true true true
Chuck Finley (108) false true false
Andy Pettitte (108) false true true
Hoyt Wilhelm (108) true true true
Tim Hudson (108) false true false
Roy Campanella (107) true true true
Darrell Evans (106) false true true
Early Wynn (106) true true true
Jim McCormick (106) false true false
Mark Buehrle (106) false true false
Roy Oswalt (106) false true false
Tommy John (105) false true false
Billy Herman (105) true true true
Gene Tenace (104) false true false
Willie Stargell (104) true true true
Whitey Ford (104) true true true
Tommy Bond (104) false true false
Wally Schang (104) false true false
Willie Davis (103) false true false
Joe Tinker (103) true true false
Bob Caruthers (103) false true true
Will Clark (103) false true true
Jeff Kent (103) false true true
Robin Ventura (103) false true false
John Olerud (103) false true false
Red Ruffing (103) true true true
Elmer Flick (102) true true true
Bob Johnson (102) false true false
Charlie Bennett (102) false true true
Charlie Buffinton (102) false true false
Billy Pierce (102) false true true
César Cedeño (102) false true false
Wilbur Wood (102) false true false
Thurman Munson (102) false true false
Sandy Koufax (102) true true true
Eppa Rixey (101) true true true
Joe Medwick (101) true true true
Jimmy Collins (101) true true true
Orel Hershiser (101) false true false
Enos Slaughter (100) true true true
Lance Berkman (100) false true false
Stan Hack (100) false false true
Roger Bresnahan (99) true false true
Willie Keeler (99) true false true
Joe Kelley (98) true false true
Bid McPhee (98) true false true
Bobby Doerr (98) true false true
Harry Stovey (98) false false true
Max Carey (97) true false true
John McGraw (97) false false true
Paul Hines (97) false false true
Burleigh Grimes (96) true false false
Waite Hoyt (96) true false false
Earl Averill (96) true false true
Tony Perez (96) true false false
John Ward (95) true false true
Al Spalding (95) false false true
Frank Chance (95) true false false
Dave Bancroft (95) true false false
Dizzy Dean (95) true false false
David Ortiz (94) true false false
Luis Aparicio (94) true false false
Kirby Puckett (94) true false false
Bill Freehan (94) false false true
Chuck Klein (93) true false false
Pete Browning (93) false false true
Heinie Groh (93) false false true
Charlie Keller (92) false false true
Joe Sewell (92) true false true
Nellie Fox (90) true false true
Kiki Cuyler (90) true false false
Addie Joss (90) true false true
Ralph Kiner (89) true false true
Mickey Welch (89) true false false
Rich Gossage (89) true false true
Johnny Evers (88) true false false
Hughie Jennings (88) true false true
Edd Roush (87) true false true
Jim Kaat (87) true false false
Travis Jackson (86) true false false
Charles Bender (86) true false false
Cupid Childs (86) false false true
Jimmy Sheckard (86) false false true
Sam Thompson (86) true false true
Hardy Richardson (85) false false true
Jim Rice (84) true false false
Sam Rice (84) true false false
Tony Oliva (84) true false false
Harry Hooper (84) true false false
George Gore (83) false false true
Herb Pennock (83) true false false
Orlando Cepeda (83) true false false
Ross Barnes (82) false false true
Heinie Manush (82) true false false
Tony Lazzeri (81) true false false
Phil Rizzuto (80) true false false
Earle Combs (80) true false false
Jack Chesbro (78) true false false
Ernie Lombardi (78) true false false
Hugh Duffy (77) true false false
Lefty Gomez (77) true false false
Joe Start (77) false false true
Hack Wilson (76) true false false
Bob Lemon (76) true false true
Jack Morris (76) true false false
Gil Hodges (74) true false false
Rabbit Maranville (74) true false false
Ezra Sutton (72) false false true
Lou Brock (71) true false false
Red Schoendienst (70) true false false
Rube Marquard (67) true false false
George Kell (67) true false false
Ray Schalk (66) true false false
Pie Traynor (65) true false false
Catfish Hunter (64) true false false
Charley Jones (63) false false true
Trevor Hoffman (63) true false false
Jim Bottomley (62) true false false
Lee Smith (62) true false false
Ross Youngs (61) true false false
Cal McVey (60) false false true
Chick Hafey (59) true false false
Harold Baines (57) true false false
Jesse Haines (57) true false false
Rick Ferrell (56) true false false
Bruce Sutter (54) true false false
Rollie Fingers (53) true false true
Bill Mazeroski (53) true false false
Freddie Lindstrom (50) true false false
Lloyd Waner (45) true false false
High Pockets Kelly (42) true false false
Lip Pike (40) false false true
Tommy McCarthy (28) true false false
Dickey Pearce (22) false false true

By Negro League MLEs

For more information about Eric Chalek’s Negro League MLEs, see our announcement.

Note: Negro League Hall of Famers Frank Grant and Bud Fowler are not included because they do not have MLE data.

Name (MLE Hall Rating) HOF HOS HOM
Joe Williams (222) true true true
Oscar Charleston (200) true true true
John Henry Lloyd (191) true true true
Satchel Paige (187) true true true
Willie Wells (179) true true true
Jud Wilson (178) true true true
Josh Gibson (170) true true true
Turkey Stearnes (169) true true true
John Beckwith (167) false true true
Bullet Rogan (160) true true true
Buck Leonard (159) true true true
Cristóbal Torriente (155) true true true
Pete Hill (149) true true true
Martín Dihigo (147) true true true
Heavy Johnson (146) false true false
Dick Redding (139) false true true
Hurley McNair (138) false true false
Grant Johnson (137) false true true
Dick Lundy (136) false true true
Dobie Moore (132) false true true
Willard Brown (131) true true true
Mule Suttles (126) true true true
José Mendéz (124) true true true
George Scales (121) false true false
Louis Santop (121) true true true
Alejandro Oms (121) false true true
Ben Taylor (113) true true false
Monte Irvin (109) true true true
Biz Mackey (107) true true true
Ray Brown (107) true true true
Hilton Smith (104) true true false
Quincy Trouppe (104) false true true
Julián Castillo (102) false true false
Rube Foster (102) true true true
Cool Papa Bell (95) true false true
Leon Day (84) true false false
Bill Foster (76) true false true
Ray Dandridge (67) true false false
Andy Cooper (52) true false false
Judy Johnson (38) true false false
Buck O'Neil (5) true false false

Only in the Hall of Fame

By Hall Rating:

  1. Burleigh Grimes (96)
  2. Waite Hoyt (96)
  3. Tony Perez (96)
  4. Frank Chance (95)
  5. Dave Bancroft (95)
  6. Dizzy Dean (95)
  7. David Ortiz (94)
  8. Luis Aparicio (94)
  9. Kirby Puckett (94)
  10. Chuck Klein (93)
  11. Kiki Cuyler (90)
  12. Mickey Welch (89)
  13. Johnny Evers (88)
  14. Jim Kaat (87)
  15. Travis Jackson (86)
  16. Charles Bender (86)
  17. Jim Rice (84)
  18. Sam Rice (84)
  19. Tony Oliva (84)
  20. Harry Hooper (84)
  21. Herb Pennock (83)
  22. Orlando Cepeda (83)
  23. Heinie Manush (82)
  24. Tony Lazzeri (81)
  25. Phil Rizzuto (80)
  26. Earle Combs (80)
  27. Jack Chesbro (78)
  28. Ernie Lombardi (78)
  29. Hugh Duffy (77)
  30. Lefty Gomez (77)
  31. Hack Wilson (76)
  32. Jack Morris (76)
  33. Gil Hodges (74)
  34. Rabbit Maranville (74)
  35. Lou Brock (71)
  36. Red Schoendienst (70)
  37. Rube Marquard (67)
  38. George Kell (67)
  39. Ray Schalk (66)
  40. Pie Traynor (65)
  41. Catfish Hunter (64)
  42. Trevor Hoffman (63)
  43. Jim Bottomley (62)
  44. Lee Smith (62)
  45. Ross Youngs (61)
  46. Chick Hafey (59)
  47. Harold Baines (57)
  48. Jesse Haines (57)
  49. Rick Ferrell (56)
  50. Bruce Sutter (54)
  51. Bill Mazeroski (53)
  52. Freddie Lindstrom (50)
  53. Lloyd Waner (45)
  54. High Pockets Kelly (42)
  55. Tommy McCarthy (28)

By MLE Hall Rating:

  1. Leon Day (84)
  2. Ray Dandridge (67)
  3. Andy Cooper (52)
  4. Judy Johnson (38)

Only in the Hall of Stats

By Hall Rating:

  1. Buddy Bell (124)
  2. Sal Bando (117)
  3. Kevin Appier (112)
  4. Bobby Bonds (112)
  5. Tony Mullane (111)
  6. Babe Adams (111)
  7. Jack Quinn (110)
  8. Chet Lemon (110)
  9. Urban Shocker (109)
  10. Chuck Finley (108)
  11. Tim Hudson (108)
  12. Jim McCormick (106)
  13. Mark Buehrle (106)
  14. Roy Oswalt (106)
  15. Tommy John (105)
  16. Gene Tenace (104)
  17. Tommy Bond (104)
  18. Wally Schang (104)
  19. Willie Davis (103)
  20. Robin Ventura (103)
  21. John Olerud (103)
  22. Bob Johnson (102)
  23. Charlie Buffinton (102)
  24. César Cedeño (102)
  25. Wilbur Wood (102)
  26. Thurman Munson (102)
  27. Orel Hershiser (101)
  28. Lance Berkman (100)

By MLE Hall Rating:

  1. Heavy Johnson (146)
  2. Hurley McNair (138)
  3. George Scales (121)
  4. Julián Castillo (102)

Only in the Hall of Merit

By Hall Rating:

  1. Pete Rose (150)
  2. Shoeless Joe Jackson (129)
  3. Stan Hack (100)
  4. Harry Stovey (98)
  5. John McGraw (97)
  6. Paul Hines (97)
  7. Al Spalding (95)
  8. Bill Freehan (94)
  9. Pete Browning (93)
  10. Heinie Groh (93)
  11. Charlie Keller (92)
  12. Cupid Childs (86)
  13. Jimmy Sheckard (86)
  14. Hardy Richardson (85)
  15. George Gore (83)
  16. Ross Barnes (82)
  17. Joe Start (77)
  18. Ezra Sutton (72)
  19. Charley Jones (63)
  20. Cal McVey (60)
  21. Lip Pike (40)
  22. Dickey Pearce (22)

By MLE Hall Rating:

In the Hall of Stats and Hall of Merit, but not the Hall of Fame

By Hall Rating:

  1. Barry Bonds (363)
  2. Roger Clemens (292)
  3. Alex Rodriguez (245)
  4. Curt Schilling (172)
  5. Lou Whitaker (144)
  6. Bill Dahlen (144)
  7. Scott Rolen (142)
  8. Bobby Grich (140)
  9. Kevin Brown (137)
  10. Rick Reuschel (136)
  11. Kenny Lofton (133)
  12. Jack Glasscock (131)
  13. Manny Ramirez (130)
  14. Luis Tiant (129)
  15. David Cone (128)
  16. Andruw Jones (127)
  17. Graig Nettles (126)
  18. Reggie Smith (126)
  19. Rafael Palmeiro (125)
  20. Willie Randolph (124)
  21. Mark McGwire (124)
  22. Dwight Evans (124)
  23. Jim Edmonds (121)
  24. Bret Saberhagen (121)
  25. Todd Helton (121)
  26. Clark Griffith (120)
  27. Ken Boyer (117)
  28. Sammy Sosa (117)
  29. Gary Sheffield (116)
  30. Dick Allen (116)
  31. Keith Hernandez (116)
  32. Dave Stieb (114)
  33. Sherry Magee (112)
  34. Joe Torre (112)
  35. Wes Ferrell (110)
  36. Bobby Abreu (110)
  37. Jim Wynn (110)
  38. Johan Santana (108)
  39. Andy Pettitte (108)
  40. Darrell Evans (106)
  41. Bob Caruthers (103)
  42. Will Clark (103)
  43. Jeff Kent (103)
  44. Charlie Bennett (102)
  45. Billy Pierce (102)

By MLE Hall Rating:

  1. John Beckwith (167)
  2. Dick Redding (139)
  3. Grant Johnson (137)
  4. Dick Lundy (136)
  5. Dobie Moore (132)
  6. Alejandro Oms (121)
  7. Quincy Trouppe (104)