Designated Hitter Rankings

25 Greatest Designated Hitters

  1. Paul Molitor dh, 1978-1998 140
  2. Frank Thomas dh, 1990-2008 139
  3. Edgar Martinez dh, 1987-2004 135
  4. David Ortiz dh, 1997-2016 95
  5. Brian Downing dh, 1973-1992 92
  6. Harold Baines dh, 1980-2001 57
  7. Chili Davis dh, 1981-1999 56
  8. Travis Hafner dh, 2002-2013 43
  9. Hal McRae dh, 1968-1987 43
  10. Don Baylor dh, 1970-1988 41
  11. Andre Thornton dh, 1973-1987 40
  12. Mike Sweeney dh, 1995-2010 38
  13. Cliff Johnson dh, 1972-1986 27
  14. Kendrys Morales dh, 2006-2016 18
  15. Ron Blomberg dh, 1969-1978 17
  16. Ken Phelps dh, 1980-1990 17
  17. Mitchell Page dh, 1977-1984 15
  18. Erubiel Durazo dh, 1999-2005 14
  19. Jack Cust dh, 2001-2011 13
  20. Billy Butler dh, 2007-2016 13
  21. Brad Fullmer dh, 1997-2004 8
  22. Reggie Jefferson dh, 1991-1999 7
  23. Josh Phelps dh, 2000-2008 6
  24. Troy Neel dh, 1992-1994 5
  25. Bob Hamelin dh, 1993-1998 5

Greatest Designated Hitters by Hall Rating

Paul Molitor Photo
  1. Paul Molitor
  2. Frank Thomas
  3. Edgar Martinez
  4. David Ortiz
  5. Brian Downing

Not in the Hall of Fame

Edgar Martinez Photo
  1. Edgar Martinez
  2. Brian Downing
  3. Harold Baines
  4. Chili Davis
  5. Hal McRae

Not in the Hall of Stats

  1. Brian Downing
  2. Harold Baines
  3. Chili Davis
  4. Hal McRae
  5. Don Baylor

Active Designated Hitters

  1. Kendrys Morales
  2. Billy Butler
  3. Miguel Sano
  4. Kennys Vargas
  5. Joey Butler

Retired but Not Yet Eligible

David Ortiz Photo
  1. David Ortiz
  2. Travis Hafner
  3. Vince Belnome
  4. Luis Jimenez