New York Metropolitans (1883-1887)

58 Greatest New York Metropolitans

  1. Tim Keefe p, 1880-1893 52
  2. Dave Orr 1b, 1883-1890 48
  3. Candy Nelson ss, 1872-1890 27
  4. Dude Esterbrook 3b, 1880-1891 12
  5. Jack Lynch p, 1881-1890 8
  6. Frank Hankinson 3b, 1878-1888 8
  7. Chief Roseman cf, 1882-1890 8
  8. Steve Brady rf, 1874-1886 8
  9. Ed Cushman p, 1883-1890 6
  10. Dasher Troy 2b, 1881-1885 4
  11. Darby O'Brien lf, 1887-1892 4
  12. Paul Radford rf, 1883-1894 3
  13. John Shaffer p, 1886-1887 2
  14. Al Mays p, 1885-1890 2
  15. Charlie Reipschlager c, 1883-1887 1
  16. Bill Holbert c, 1876-1888 1
  17. John O'Rourke cf, 1879-1883 1
  18. Bill Fagan p, 1887-1888 0
  19. Tom Forster 2b, 1882-1886 0
  20. Tony Murphy c, 1884 0
  21. Jones 3b, 1885 0
  22. Fred O'Neill rf, 1887 0
  23. Henry Oxley c, 1884 0
  24. Peter Connell 3b, 1886-1890 0
  25. Lip Pike cf, 1871-1887 0
  26. Stump Wiedman p, 1880-1888 0
  27. Mortimer Hogan rf, 1884-1888 0
  28. Joe Crotty c, 1882-1886 0
  29. Charlie Hall cf, 1887 0
  30. Sadie Houck ss, 1879-1887 0
  31. Jim Donahue c, 1886-1891 0
  32. Tom Kinslow c, 1886-1898 0
  33. Chief Zimmer c, 1884-1903 0
  34. Bill Collins c, 1887-1892 0
  35. Dick Pierson 2b, 1885 0
  36. Clarence Cross ss, 1884-1887 0
  37. Gracie Pierce 2b, 1882-1884 0
  38. Charley Jones lf, 1875-1888 0
  39. Jimmy Knowles 3b, 1884-1892 0
  40. Charlie Parsons p, 1886-1890 0
  41. Jim Reilly 2b, 1885 0
  42. Henry Brooks 1886 0
  43. John Meister 2b, 1886-1887 0
  44. Steve Behel lf, 1884-1886 0
  45. Cal Broughton c, 1883-1888 0
  46. James McMullin p, 1887 0
  47. Cyclone Ryan 1b, 1887-1891 -1
  48. Jon Morrison cf, 1884-1887 -1
  49. Andy Sommers c, 1887-1890 -1
  50. Tom McLaughlin ss, 1883-1891 -1
  51. Sam Crane 2b, 1880-1890 -1
  52. Elmer Foster cf, 1886-1891 -1
  53. Tom O'Brien 2b, 1882-1890 -1
  54. Buck Becannon p, 1884-1887 -1
  55. Joe Gerhardt 2b, 1873-1891 -2
  56. Ed Bagley p, 1884-1885 -2
  57. Doug Crothers p, 1884-1885 -2
  58. Ed Kennedy lf, 1883-1886 -3

Greatest New York Metropolitans by Hall Rating

Tim Keefe Photo
  1. Tim Keefe
  2. Dave Orr
  3. Candy Nelson
  4. Dude Esterbrook
  5. Jack Lynch

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the New York Metropolitans (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: Charlie Reipschlager (1)
  2. 1B: Dave Orr (48)
  3. 2B: Dasher Troy (4)
  4. 3B: Dude Esterbrook (12)
  5. SS: Candy Nelson (27)
  6. LF: Darby O'Brien (4)
  7. CF: Chief Roseman (8)
  8. RF: Steve Brady (8)
  9. P: Tim Keefe (52)

Bench

  1. 3B: Frank Hankinson (8)
  2. RF: Paul Radford (3)
  3. C: Bill Holbert (1)
  4. CF: John O'Rourke (1)
  5. 2B: Tom Forster (0)
  6. C: Tony Murphy (0)
  7. 3B: Jones (0)

Bullpen

  1. P: Jack Lynch (8)
  2. P: Ed Cushman (6)
  3. P: John Shaffer (2)
  4. P: Al Mays (2)
  5. P: Bill Fagan (0)
  6. P: Stump Wiedman (0)
  7. P: Charlie Parsons (0)
  8. P: James McMullin (0)
  9. P: Buck Becannon (-1)