New York Metropolitans (1883-1887)

58 Greatest New York Metropolitans

  1. Tim Keefe p, 1880–1893 52
  2. Dave Orr 1b, 1883–1890 48
  3. Candy Nelson ss, 1872–1890 27
  4. Dude Esterbrook 3b, 1880–1891 12
  5. Jack Lynch p, 1881–1890 8
  6. Frank Hankinson 3b, 1878–1888 8
  7. James Roseman cf, 1882–1890 8
  8. Steve Brady rf, 1874–1886 8
  9. Ed Cushman p, 1883–1890 6
  10. Dasher Troy 2b, 1881–1885 4
  11. Darby O'Brien lf, 1887–1892 4
  12. Paul Radford rf, 1883–1894 3
  13. John Shaffer p, 1886–1887 2
  14. Al Mays p, 1885–1890 2
  15. Charlie Reipschlager c, 1883–1887 1
  16. Bill Holbert c, 1876–1888 1
  17. John O'Rourke cf, 1879–1883 1
  18. Bill Fagan p, 1887–1888 0
  19. Tom Forster 2b, 1882–1886 0
  20. Tony Murphy c, 1884 0
  21. Jones 3b, 1885 0
  22. Fred O'Neill rf, 1887 0
  23. Henry Oxley c, 1884 0
  24. Lip Pike cf, 1871–1887 0
  25. Peter Connell 3b, 1886–1890 0
  26. Stump Weidman p, 1880–1888 0
  27. Mortimer Hogan rf, 1884–1888 0
  28. Joe Crotty c, 1882–1886 0
  29. Charlie Hall cf, 1887 0
  30. Sadie Houck ss, 1879–1887 0
  31. Jim Donahue c, 1886–1891 0
  32. Charles Zimmer c, 1884–1903 0
  33. Tom Kinslow c, 1886–1898 0
  34. Bill Collins c, 1887–1892 0
  35. Dick Pierson 2b, 1885 0
  36. Clarence Cross ss, 1884–1887 0
  37. Gracie Pierce 2b, 1882–1884 0
  38. Charley Jones lf, 1875–1888 0
  39. Jimmy Knowles 3b, 1884–1892 0
  40. Charlie Parsons p, 1886–1890 0
  41. Jim Reilly 2b, 1885 0
  42. Fred Mauer p, 1886 0
  43. John Meister 2b, 1886–1887 0
  44. Steve Behel lf, 1884–1886 0
  45. Cal Broughton c, 1883–1888 0
  46. James McMullin p, 1887 0
  47. Cyclone Ryan 1b, 1887–1891 -1
  48. Jon Morrison cf, 1884–1887 -1
  49. Andy Sommers c, 1887–1890 -1
  50. Tom McLaughlin ss, 1883–1891 -1
  51. Sam Crane 2b, 1880–1890 -1
  52. Elmer Foster cf, 1886–1891 -1
  53. Tom O'Brien 2b, 1882–1890 -1
  54. Buck Becannon p, 1884–1887 -1
  55. Joe Gerhardt 2b, 1873–1891 -2
  56. Ed Bagley p, 1884–1885 -2
  57. Doug Crothers p, 1884–1885 -2
  58. Ed Kennedy lf, 1883–1886 -3

Greatest New York Metropolitans by Hall Rating

Tim Keefe Photo
  1. Tim Keefe
  2. Dave Orr
  3. Candy Nelson
  4. Dude Esterbrook
  5. Jack Lynch

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the New York Metropolitans (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: Charlie Reipschlager (1)
  2. 1B: Dave Orr (48)
  3. 2B: Dasher Troy (4)
  4. 3B: Dude Esterbrook (12)
  5. SS: Candy Nelson (27)
  6. LF: Darby O'Brien (4)
  7. CF: James Roseman (8)
  8. RF: Steve Brady (8)
  9. P: Tim Keefe (52)

Bench

  1. 3B: Frank Hankinson (8)
  2. RF: Paul Radford (3)
  3. C: Bill Holbert (1)
  4. CF: John O'Rourke (1)
  5. 2B: Tom Forster (0)
  6. C: Tony Murphy (0)
  7. 3B: Jones (0)

Bullpen

  1. P: Jack Lynch (8)
  2. P: Ed Cushman (6)
  3. P: John Shaffer (2)
  4. P: Al Mays (2)
  5. P: Bill Fagan (0)
  6. P: Stump Weidman (0)
  7. P: Charlie Parsons (0)
  8. P: Fred Mauer (0)
  9. P: James McMullin (0)