New York Giants (1890)

17 Greatest New York Giants

  1. Roger Connor 1b, 1880-1897 14
  2. Buck Ewing c, 1880-1897 10
  3. Tim Keefe p, 1880-1893 8
  4. Jim O'Rourke lf, 1872-1904 6
  5. George Gore cf, 1879-1892 5
  6. John Ewing p, 1883-1891 3
  7. Hank O'Day p, 1884-1890 3
  8. Ed Crane p, 1884-1893 1
  9. Mike Slattery cf, 1884-1891 0
  10. Fred Dunlap 2b, 1880-1891 0
  11. William Brown 1b, 1887-1894 0
  12. Gil Hatfield ss, 1885-1895 0
  13. Danny Richardson 2b, 1884-1894 0
  14. Farmer Vaughn c, 1886-1899 -1
  15. Dan Shannon 2b, 1889-1891 -1
  16. Dick Johnston cf, 1884-1891 -1
  17. Art Whitney 3b, 1880-1891 -1

Greatest New York Giants by Hall Rating

Roger Connor Photo
  1. Roger Connor
  2. Buck Ewing
  3. Tim Keefe
  4. Jim O'Rourke
  5. George Gore

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the New York Giants (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: Buck Ewing (10)
  2. 1B: Roger Connor (14)
  3. 2B: Fred Dunlap (0)
  4. 3B: Art Whitney (-1)
  5. SS: Gil Hatfield (0)
  6. LF: Jim O'Rourke (6)
  7. CF: George Gore (5)
  8. RF:
  9. P: Tim Keefe (8)

Bench

  1. CF: Mike Slattery (0)
  2. 1B: William Brown (0)
  3. 2B: Danny Richardson (0)
  4. C: Farmer Vaughn (-1)
  5. 2B: Dan Shannon (-1)
  6. CF: Dick Johnston (-1)

Bullpen

  1. P: John Ewing (3)
  2. P: Hank O'Day (3)
  3. P: Ed Crane (1)