New York Mutuals (1871-1875)

36 Greatest New York Mutuals

  1. Bobby Mathews p, 1871-1887 48
  2. Dave Eggler cf, 1871-1885 18
  3. Joe Start 1b, 1871-1886 17
  4. Candy Cummings p, 1872-1877 12
  5. John Hatfield lf, 1871-1876 11
  6. Nat Hicks c, 1872-1877 7
  7. Rynie Wolters p, 1871-1873 7
  8. Dick Higham rf, 1871-1880 5
  9. Jim Holdsworth cf, 1872-1884 4
  10. Count Gedney lf, 1872-1875 4
  11. George Bechtel rf, 1871-1876 3
  12. Candy Nelson ss, 1872-1890 3
  13. Jack Burdock 2b, 1872-1891 3
  14. Dickey Pearce ss, 1871-1877 3
  15. John McMullin lf, 1871-1875 3
  16. Chick Fulmer ss, 1871-1884 2
  17. Tom Carey ss, 1871-1879 2
  18. Jimmy Hallinan ss, 1871-1878 1
  19. Doug Allison c, 1871-1883 1
  20. Bob Ferguson 3b, 1871-1884 1
  21. Charlie Smith 3b, 1871 1
  22. Bill Boyd 3b, 1872-1875 1
  23. Charlie Mills c, 1871-1872 1
  24. Jack Remsen cf, 1872-1884 0
  25. Billy Geer ss, 1874-1885 0
  26. Joe Gerhardt 2b, 1873-1891 0
  27. Orator Shafer rf, 1874-1890 0
  28. Alfred Metcalfe 3b, 1875 0
  29. Frank Fleet 2b, 1871-1875 0
  30. Billy Barnie c, 1874-1886 0
  31. Nealy Phelps rf, 1871-1876 0
  32. Steve Bellan 3b, 1871-1873 0
  33. Eddie Booth rf, 1872-1876 -1
  34. Pat McGee cf, 1874-1875 -1
  35. Tom Patterson rf, 1871-1875 -1
  36. Phonney Martin rf, 1872-1873 -2

Greatest New York Mutuals by Hall Rating

Bobby Mathews Photo
  1. Bobby Mathews
  2. Dave Eggler
  3. Joe Start
  4. Candy Cummings
  5. John Hatfield

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the New York Mutuals (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: Nat Hicks (7)
  2. 1B: Joe Start (17)
  3. 2B: Jack Burdock (3)
  4. 3B: Bob Ferguson (1)
  5. SS: Candy Nelson (3)
  6. LF: John Hatfield (11)
  7. CF: Dave Eggler (18)
  8. RF: Dick Higham (5)
  9. P: Bobby Mathews (48)

Bench

  1. CF: Jim Holdsworth (4)
  2. LF: Count Gedney (4)
  3. RF: George Bechtel (3)
  4. SS: Dickey Pearce (3)
  5. LF: John McMullin (3)
  6. SS: Chick Fulmer (2)
  7. SS: Tom Carey (2)

Bullpen

  1. P: Candy Cummings (12)
  2. P: Rynie Wolters (7)