New Haven Elm Citys (1875)

25 Greatest New Haven Elm Citys

  1. Tim McGinley c, 1875-1876 3
  2. Sam Wright ss, 1875-1881 2
  3. Charlie Gould 1b, 1871-1877 1
  4. Ed Somerville 2b, 1875-1876 1
  5. Billy Geer ss, 1874-1885 1
  6. Charlie Pabor lf, 1871-1875 1
  7. Jumbo Latham 1b, 1875-1884 1
  8. Henry Luff 3b, 1875-1884 0
  9. Fred Goldsmith p, 1875-1884 0
  10. Sullivan rf, 1875 0
  11. Evans lf, 1875 0
  12. Lester Dole cf, 1875 0
  13. George Trenwith 3b, 1875 0
  14. Tom Barlow c, 1872-1875 0
  15. George Knight p, 1875 0
  16. John Cassidy rf, 1875-1885 0
  17. Rit Harrison 1875 0
  18. Booth ss, 1875 0
  19. John McKelvey rf, 1875 0
  20. John Smith ss, 1873-1875 0
  21. Studs Bancker c, 1875 0
  22. Jim Keenan c, 1875-1891 -1
  23. Tricky Nichols p, 1875-1882 -1
  24. Jim Tipper lf, 1872-1875 -2
  25. Johnny Ryan lf, 1873-1877 -2

Greatest New Haven Elm Citys by Hall Rating

  1. Tim McGinley
  2. Sam Wright
  3. Charlie Gould
  4. Ed Somerville
  5. Billy Geer

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the New Haven Elm Citys (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: Tim McGinley (3)
  2. 1B: Charlie Gould (1)
  3. 2B: Ed Somerville (1)
  4. 3B: Henry Luff (0)
  5. SS: Sam Wright (2)
  6. LF: Charlie Pabor (1)
  7. CF: Lester Dole (0)
  8. RF: Sullivan (0)
  9. P: Fred Goldsmith (0)

Bench

  1. SS: Billy Geer (1)
  2. 1B: Jumbo Latham (1)
  3. LF: Evans (0)
  4. 3B: George Trenwith (0)
  5. C: Tom Barlow (0)
  6. RF: John Cassidy (0)
  7. Rit Harrison (0)

Bullpen

  1. P: George Knight (0)
  2. P: Tricky Nichols (-1)