Middletown Mansfields (1872)

12 Greatest Middletown Mansfields

  1. Tim Murnane 1b, 1872-1884 3
  2. John Clapp c, 1872-1883 2
  3. Jim O'Rourke lf, 1872-1904 1
  4. Eddie Booth rf, 1872-1876 1
  5. Ham Allen ss, 1872 1
  6. Frank McCarton cf, 1872 1
  7. Billy Arnold rf, 1872 0
  8. Asa Brainard p, 1871-1874 -1
  9. Jim Tipper lf, 1872-1875 -1
  10. Frank Buttery rf, 1872 -2
  11. George Fields 3b, 1872 -2
  12. Cy Bentley p, 1872 -3

Greatest Middletown Mansfields by Hall Rating

  1. Tim Murnane
  2. John Clapp
  3. Jim O'Rourke
  4. Eddie Booth
  5. Ham Allen

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the Middletown Mansfields (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: John Clapp (2)
  2. 1B: Tim Murnane (3)
  3. 2B:
  4. 3B: George Fields (-2)
  5. SS: Ham Allen (1)
  6. LF: Jim O'Rourke (1)
  7. CF: Frank McCarton (1)
  8. RF: Eddie Booth (1)
  9. P: Asa Brainard (-1)

Bench

  1. RF: Billy Arnold (0)
  2. LF: Jim Tipper (-1)
  3. RF: Frank Buttery (-2)

Bullpen

  1. P: Cy Bentley (-3)