Cincinnati Reds (1876-1880)

Greatest Cincinnati Reds

  1. Deacon White 3b, 1871-1890 19
  2. Charley Jones lf, 1875-1888 18
  3. King Kelly rf, 1878-1893 14
  4. John Clapp c, 1872-1883 10
  5. Cal McVey 1b, 1871-1879 7
  6. Joe Gerhardt 2b, 1873-1891 7
  7. Buttercup Dickerson lf, 1878-1885 6
  8. Lip Pike cf, 1871-1887 4
  9. Chub Sullivan 1b, 1877-1880 4
  10. Will White p, 1877-1886 4
  11. Pete Hotaling cf, 1879-1888 4
  12. Bobby Mitchell p, 1877-1882 3
  13. Ross Barnes 2b, 1871-1881 3
  14. Billy Geer ss, 1874-1885 2
  15. Levi Meyerle 3b, 1871-1884 1
  16. Charlie Gould 1b, 1871-1877 1
  17. Blondie Purcell lf, 1879-1890 1
  18. Bob Addy rf, 1871-1877 1
  19. Jack Manning rf, 1873-1886 1
  20. George Miller c, 1877-1884 1
  21. Jimmy Hallinan ss, 1871-1878 1
  22. Dave Pierson c, 1876 1
  23. Andy Leonard lf, 1871-1880 0
  24. Mike Mansell lf, 1879-1884 0
  25. Nat Hicks c, 1872-1877 0
  26. Hick Carpenter 3b, 1879-1892 0
  27. Billy Redmond ss, 1875-1878 0
  28. Harry Smith 2b, 1877-1889 0
  29. Will Foley 3b, 1875-1884 0
  30. Ned Cuthbert lf, 1871-1884 0
  31. John Magner cf, 1879 0
  32. Jack Neagle p, 1879-1884 0
  33. Johnny Ryan lf, 1873-1877 0
  34. Sam Wright ss, 1875-1881 0
  35. Sam Field c, 1875-1876 0
  36. Charlie Sweasy 2b, 1871-1878 0
  37. Mike Burke ss, 1879 0
  38. Joe Sommer lf, 1880-1890 0
  39. Bobby Clack cf, 1874-1876 -1
  40. Dale Williams p, 1876 -1
  41. Candy Cummings p, 1872-1877 -1
  42. Lou Say ss, 1873-1884 -1
  43. Charlie Reilley c, 1879-1884 -1
  44. Henry Kessler ss, 1873-1877 -1
  45. Cherokee Fisher p, 1871-1878 -1
  46. John Reilly 1b, 1880-1891 -1
  47. Scott Hastings c, 1871-1877 -2
  48. Harry Wheeler lf, 1878-1884 -2
  49. Pop Smith 2b, 1880-1891 -2
  50. Amos Booth c, 1876-1882 -2
  51. Bobby Mathews p, 1871-1887 -2
  52. Redleg Snyder lf, 1876-1884 -2
  53. Dory Dean p, 1876 -2

Greatest Cincinnati Reds by Hall Rating

Deacon White Photo
  1. Deacon White
  2. Charley Jones
  3. King Kelly
  4. John Clapp
  5. Cal McVey

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the Cincinnati Reds (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: John Clapp (10)
  2. 1B: Cal McVey (7)
  3. 2B: Joe Gerhardt (7)
  4. 3B: Deacon White (19)
  5. SS: Billy Geer (2)
  6. LF: Charley Jones (18)
  7. CF: Lip Pike (4)
  8. RF: King Kelly (14)
  9. P: Will White (4)

Bench

  1. LF: Buttercup Dickerson (6)
  2. 1B: Chub Sullivan (4)
  3. CF: Pete Hotaling (4)
  4. 2B: Ross Barnes (3)
  5. 3B: Levi Meyerle (1)
  6. 1B: Charlie Gould (1)
  7. LF: Blondie Purcell (1)

Bullpen

  1. P: Bobby Mitchell (3)
  2. P: Jack Neagle (0)
  3. P: Dale Williams (-1)
  4. P: Candy Cummings (-1)
  5. P: Cherokee Fisher (-1)
  6. P: Bobby Mathews (-2)
  7. P: Dory Dean (-2)