Cincinnati Reds (1876-1880)

53 Greatest Cincinnati Reds

  1. Deacon White 3b, 1871–1890 19
  2. Charley Jones lf, 1875–1888 18
  3. King Kelly rf, 1878–1893 14
  4. John Clapp c, 1872–1883 10
  5. Cal McVey 1b, 1871–1879 7
  6. Joe Gerhardt 2b, 1873–1891 7
  7. Buttercup Dickerson lf, 1878–1885 6
  8. Lip Pike cf, 1871–1887 4
  9. Chub Sullivan 1b, 1877–1880 4
  10. Will White p, 1877–1886 4
  11. Pete Hotaling cf, 1879–1888 4
  12. Bobby Mitchell p, 1877–1882 3
  13. Ross Barnes 2b, 1871–1881 3
  14. Billy Geer ss, 1874–1885 2
  15. Levi Meyerle 3b, 1871–1884 1
  16. Charlie Gould 1b, 1871–1877 1
  17. Blondie Purcell lf, 1879–1890 1
  18. Bob Addy rf, 1871–1877 1
  19. Jack Manning rf, 1873–1886 1
  20. George Miller c, 1877–1884 1
  21. Jimmy Hallinan ss, 1871–1878 1
  22. Dave Pierson c, 1876 1
  23. Andy Leonard lf, 1871–1880 0
  24. Mike Mansell lf, 1879–1884 0
  25. Nat Hicks c, 1872–1877 0
  26. Hick Carpenter 3b, 1879–1892 0
  27. Billy Redmond ss, 1875–1878 0
  28. Harry Smith 2b, 1877–1889 0
  29. Will Foley 3b, 1875–1884 0
  30. Ned Cuthbert lf, 1871–1884 0
  31. John Magner cf, 1879 0
  32. Jack Neagle p, 1879–1884 0
  33. Johnny Ryan lf, 1873–1877 0
  34. Sam Wright ss, 1875–1881 0
  35. Sam Field c, 1875–1876 0
  36. Charlie Sweasy 2b, 1871–1878 0
  37. Mike Burke ss, 1879 0
  38. Joe Sommer lf, 1880–1890 0
  39. Bobby Clack cf, 1874–1876 -1
  40. Dale Williams p, 1876 -1
  41. Candy Cummings p, 1872–1877 -1
  42. Lou Say ss, 1873–1884 -1
  43. Charlie Reilley c, 1879–1884 -1
  44. Henry Kessler ss, 1873–1877 -1
  45. Cherokee Fisher p, 1871–1878 -1
  46. John Reilly 1b, 1880–1891 -2
  47. Scott Hastings c, 1871–1877 -2
  48. Pop Smith 2b, 1880–1891 -2
  49. Harry Wheeler lf, 1878–1884 -2
  50. Amos Booth c, 1876–1882 -2
  51. Bobby Mathews p, 1871–1887 -2
  52. Redleg Snyder lf, 1876–1884 -2
  53. Dory Dean p, 1876 -2

Greatest Cincinnati Reds by Hall Rating

Deacon White Photo
  1. Deacon White
  2. Charley Jones
  3. King Kelly
  4. John Clapp
  5. Cal McVey

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the Cincinnati Reds (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: John Clapp (10)
  2. 1B: Cal McVey (7)
  3. 2B: Joe Gerhardt (7)
  4. 3B: Deacon White (19)
  5. SS: Billy Geer (2)
  6. LF: Charley Jones (18)
  7. CF: Lip Pike (4)
  8. RF: King Kelly (14)
  9. P: Will White (4)

Bench

  1. LF: Buttercup Dickerson (6)
  2. 1B: Chub Sullivan (4)
  3. CF: Pete Hotaling (4)
  4. 2B: Ross Barnes (3)
  5. 3B: Levi Meyerle (1)
  6. 1B: Charlie Gould (1)
  7. LF: Blondie Purcell (1)

Bullpen

  1. P: Bobby Mitchell (3)
  2. P: Jack Neagle (0)
  3. P: Dale Williams (-1)
  4. P: Candy Cummings (-1)
  5. P: Cherokee Fisher (-1)
  6. P: Bobby Mathews (-2)
  7. P: Dory Dean (-2)