Cleveland Indians (since 1901)

Also played as Cleveland Naps, Cleveland Bronchos, and Cleveland Blues.

200 Greatest Cleveland Indians

  1. Nap Lajoie 2b, 1896–1916 170
  2. Tris Speaker cf, 1907–1928 156
  3. Lou Boudreau ss, 1938–1952 130
  4. Bob Feller p, 1936–1956 129
  5. Stan Coveleski p, 1912–1928 110
  6. Kenny Lofton cf, 1991–2007 97
  7. Earl Averill cf, 1929–1941 96
  8. Jim Thome 1b, 1991–2012 94
  9. Addie Joss p, 1902–1910 89
  10. Larry Doby cf, 1942–1959 89
  11. Sam McDowell p, 1961–1975 86
  12. Mel Harder p, 1928–1947 85
  13. Jose Ramirez 3b, 2013–2022 81
  14. Joe Sewell ss, 1920–1933 79
  15. Bob Lemon p, 1941–1958 76
  16. Early Wynn p, 1939–1963 74
  17. Shoeless Joe Jackson rf, 1908–1920 73
  18. Corey Kluber p, 2011–2022 68
  19. Wes Ferrell p, 1927–1941 67
  20. Bill Bradley 3b, 1899–1915 67
  21. Al Rosen 3b, 1947–1956 65
  22. Terry Turner ss, 1901–1919 61
  23. Jim Bagby p, 1912–1923 59
  24. Gaylord Perry p, 1962–1983 58
  25. Mike Garcia p, 1948–1961 58
  26. George Uhle p, 1919–1936 58
  27. Elmer Flick rf, 1898–1910 58
  28. Ken Keltner 3b, 1937–1950 57
  29. Manny Ramirez lf, 1993–2011 57
  30. Francisco Lindor ss, 2015–2022 56
  31. Luis Tiant p, 1964–1982 53
  32. Grady Sizemore cf, 2004–2015 53
  33. Albert Belle lf, 1989–2000 53
  34. Willis Hudlin p, 1926–1944 52
  35. Carlos Santana 1b, 2010–2022 52
  36. Bobby Avila 2b, 1949–1959 52
  37. Hal Trosky 1b, 1933–1946 52
  38. Ray Chapman ss, 1912–1920 50
  39. Jeff Heath lf, 1936–1949 49
  40. Charles Nagy p, 1990–2003 48
  41. CC Sabathia p, 2001–2019 48
  42. Omar Vizquel ss, 1989–2012 48
  43. Steve O'Neill c, 1911–1928 48
  44. Carlos Carrasco p, 2009–2022 47
  45. Vean Gregg p, 1911–1925 46
  46. Bartolo Colon p, 1997–2018 45
  47. Bert Blyleven p, 1970–1992 44
  48. Travis Hafner dh, 2002–2013 43
  49. Tom Candiotti p, 1983–1999 42
  50. Michael Brantley lf, 2009–2022 42
  51. Rocky Colavito rf, 1955–1968 42
  52. Roberto Alomar 2b, 1988–2004 41
  53. Sonny Siebert p, 1964–1975 41
  54. Buddy Bell 3b, 1972–1989 40
  55. Shin-Soo Choo rf, 2005–2020 40
  56. Joe Gordon 2b, 1938–1950 39
  57. Johnny Allen p, 1932–1944 38
  58. Victor Martinez c, 2002–2018 37
  59. Carlos Baerga 2b, 1990–2005 35
  60. Shane Bieber p, 2018–2022 35
  61. Woodie Held ss, 1954–1969 34
  62. Graig Nettles 3b, 1967–1988 34
  63. Toby Harrah 3b, 1969–1986 33
  64. Asdrubal Cabrera ss, 2007–2021 33
  65. Jason Kipnis 2b, 2011–2020 33
  66. Charlie Jamieson lf, 1915–1932 33
  67. John Romano c, 1958–1967 32
  68. Brett Butler cf, 1981–1997 31
  69. Andre Thornton dh, 1973–1987 31
  70. Dale Mitchell lf, 1946–1956 31
  71. Guy Morton p, 1914–1924 30
  72. Jake Miller p, 1924–1933 30
  73. Herb Score p, 1955–1962 30
  74. Steve Gromek p, 1941–1957 29
  75. Greg Swindell p, 1986–2002 29
  76. Cliff Lee p, 2002–2014 29
  77. Mike Clevinger p, 2016–2022 28
  78. Trevor Bauer p, 2012–2021 27
  79. Yan Gomes c, 2012–2022 27
  80. Ray Narleski p, 1954–1959 27
  81. Joe Shaute p, 1922–1934 26
  82. Dennis Martinez p, 1976–1998 25
  83. Dennis Eckersley p, 1975–1998 25
  84. Sandy Alomar c, 1988–2007 25
  85. Brook Jacoby 3b, 1981–1992 25
  86. Steve Hargan p, 1965–1977 25
  87. Julio Franco ss, 1982–2007 24
  88. Sherry Smith p, 1911–1927 24
  89. Ed Morgan 1b, 1928–1934 24
  90. Bill Bernhard p, 1899–1907 24
  91. Joe Vosmik lf, 1930–1944 24
  92. Joe Azcue c, 1960–1972 23
  93. Jhonny Peralta ss, 2003–2017 23
  94. Eric Plunk p, 1986–1999 23
  95. Doug Jones p, 1982–2000 23
  96. Earl Moore p, 1901–1914 23
  97. Odell Hale 2b, 1931–1941 23
  98. Rick Waits p, 1973–1985 22
  99. Jose Mesa p, 1987–2007 22
  100. Ray Fosse c, 1967–1979 22
  101. Casey Blake 3b, 1999–2011 22
  102. Gary Bell p, 1958–1969 22
  103. Mike Hargrove 1b, 1974–1985 22
  104. Clint Brown p, 1928–1942 22
  105. Joe Carter lf, 1983–1998 21
  106. Minnie Miñoso lf, 1946–1980 21
  107. Oral Hildebrand p, 1931–1940 21
  108. Tito Francona lf, 1956–1970 21
  109. George Burns 1b, 1914–1929 21
  110. Larry Gardner 3b, 1908–1924 21
  111. Jay Clarke c, 1905–1920 21
  112. Willie Mitchell p, 1909–1919 20
  113. Don Mossi p, 1954–1965 20
  114. Jake Westbrook p, 2000–2013 20
  115. Cy Falkenberg p, 1903–1917 19
  116. Dan Spillner p, 1974–1985 19
  117. Cody Allen p, 2012–2019 19
  118. Bob Rhoads p, 1902–1909 19
  119. Al Smith rf, 1946–1964 18
  120. Dave Burba p, 1990–2004 18
  121. Charlie Hickman 1b, 1897–1908 18
  122. Jim Piersall cf, 1950–1967 18
  123. Roy Cullenbine rf, 1938–1947 18
  124. Rafael Betancourt p, 2003–2015 18
  125. Len Barker p, 1976–1987 18
  126. Duke Sims c, 1964–1974 18
  127. Andres Gimenez ss, 2020–2022 17
  128. Johnny Hodapp 2b, 1925–1933 17
  129. Sid Monge p, 1975–1984 17
  130. Braggo Roth rf, 1914–1921 17
  131. David Justice rf, 1989–2002 17
  132. Frank Duffy ss, 1970–1979 17
  133. Rick Manning cf, 1975–1987 17
  134. Paul Shuey p, 1994–2007 16
  135. Roberto Perez c, 2014–2022 16
  136. Rick Sutcliffe p, 1976–1994 16
  137. Frankie Pytlak c, 1932–1946 16
  138. Jim Perry p, 1959–1975 16
  139. Fred Blanding p, 1910–1914 16
  140. George Stovall 1b, 1904–1915 16
  141. Ron Hassey c, 1978–1991 16
  142. Danny Salazar p, 2013–2019 15
  143. Lew Fonseca 1b, 1921–1933 15
  144. Luke Easter 1b, 1947–1954 15
  145. Les Fleming 1b, 1939–1949 15
  146. Steve Karsay p, 1993–2006 15
  147. Harry Bemis c, 1902–1910 15
  148. Garland Buckeye p, 1918–1928 15
  149. Ronnie Belliard 2b, 1998–2010 15
  150. Coco Crisp cf, 2002–2016 15
  151. Elmer Smith rf, 1914–1925 15
  152. Vic Davalillo cf, 1963–1980 15
  153. Bruce Campbell rf, 1930–1942 15
  154. John Farrell p, 1987–1996 15
  155. Jim Kern p, 1974–1986 14
  156. Riggs Stephenson lf, 1921–1934 14
  157. Harry Bay cf, 1901–1908 14
  158. Joe Smith p, 2007–2022 14
  159. Lloyd Brown p, 1925–1940 14
  160. Monte Pearson p, 1932–1941 14
  161. Justin Masterson p, 2008–2015 14
  162. Jack Kralick p, 1959–1967 14
  163. Orel Hershiser p, 1983–2000 14
  164. Jack Graney lf, 1908–1922 14
  165. Ray Boone 3b, 1948–1960 14
  166. Emmanuel Clase p, 2019–2022 14
  167. Brian Giles rf, 1995–2009 14
  168. Stan Williams p, 1958–1972 14
  169. Cal McLish p, 1944–1964 13
  170. Hank Edwards rf, 1941–1953 13
  171. Roberto Hernandez p, 2006–2016 13
  172. Al Benton p, 1934–1952 13
  173. Michael Jackson p, 1986–2004 13
  174. Buddy Rosar c, 1939–1951 13
  175. Joe Harris 1b, 1914–1928 12
  176. Kelly Shoppach c, 2005–2013 12
  177. Bill Steen p, 1912–1915 12
  178. Bud Black p, 1981–1995 12
  179. Ellis Burks cf, 1987–2004 12
  180. Bryan Shaw p, 2011–2022 12
  181. Bob Wickman p, 1992–2007 12
  182. Travis Fryman 3b, 1990–2002 12
  183. Cal Quantrill p, 2019–2022 12
  184. David Riske p, 1999–2010 12
  185. Max Alvis 3b, 1962–1970 12
  186. Dave LaRoche p, 1970–1983 12
  187. Fritz Coumbe p, 1914–1921 11
  188. Rico Carty lf, 1963–1979 11
  189. Zach Plesac p, 2019–2022 11
  190. Jim Bibby p, 1972–1984 11
  191. George Strickland ss, 1950–1960 11
  192. Derek Lilliquist p, 1989–1996 11
  193. Andrew Miller p, 2006–2021 11
  194. Vic Power 1b, 1954–1965 11
  195. Lonnie Chisenhall 3b, 2011–2018 11
  196. Ted Easterly c, 1909–1915 11
  197. Steven Kwan lf, 2022 11
  198. Roy Weatherly cf, 1936–1950 11
  199. John Denny p, 1974–1986 11
  200. Chad Ogea p, 1994–1999 11

Greatest Cleveland Indians by Hall Rating

Nap Lajoie Photo
  1. Nap Lajoie
  2. Tris Speaker
  3. Lou Boudreau
  4. Bob Feller
  5. Stan Coveleski

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the Cleveland Indians (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: Steve O'Neill (48)
  2. 1B: Jim Thome (94)
  3. 2B: Nap Lajoie (170)
  4. 3B: Jose Ramirez (81)
  5. SS: Lou Boudreau (130)
  6. LF: Manny Ramirez (57)
  7. CF: Tris Speaker (156)
  8. RF: Shoeless Joe Jackson (73)
  9. P: Bob Feller (129)

Bench

  1. CF: Kenny Lofton (97)
  2. CF: Earl Averill (96)
  3. CF: Larry Doby (89)
  4. SS: Joe Sewell (79)
  5. 3B: Bill Bradley (67)
  6. 3B: Al Rosen (65)
  7. SS: Terry Turner (61)

Bullpen

  1. P: Stan Coveleski (110)
  2. P: Addie Joss (89)
  3. P: Sam McDowell (86)
  4. P: Mel Harder (85)
  5. P: Bob Lemon (76)
  6. P: Early Wynn (74)
  7. P: Corey Kluber (68)
  8. P: Wes Ferrell (67)
  9. P: Jim Bagby (59)