Cleveland Indians (since 1901)

Also played as Cleveland Naps, Cleveland Bronchos, and Cleveland Blues.

20 Greatest Cleveland Indians by Hall Rating

Cleveland Indians Season-by-Season by Wins Above Replacement

200 Greatest Cleveland Indians

  1. Nap Lajoie 2b, 1896-1916 172
  2. Tris Speaker cf, 1907-1928 156
  3. Lou Boudreau ss, 1938-1952 130
  4. Bob Feller p, 1936-1956 130
  5. Stan Coveleski p, 1912-1928 107
  6. Kenny Lofton cf, 1991-2007 97
  7. Jim Thome 1b, 1991-2012 94
  8. Larry Doby cf, 1947-1959 90
  9. Earl Averill cf, 1929-1941 88
  10. Sam McDowell p, 1961-1975 86
  11. Addie Joss p, 1902-1910 85
  12. Mel Harder p, 1928-1947 85
  13. Joe Sewell ss, 1920-1933 80
  14. Bob Lemon p, 1941-1958 76
  15. Early Wynn p, 1939-1963 74
  16. Joe Jackson lf, 1908-1920 74
  17. Bill Bradley 3b, 1899-1915 68
  18. Al Rosen 3b, 1947-1956 66
  19. Wes Ferrell p, 1927-1941 66
  20. Terry Turner ss, 1901-1919 62
  21. Gaylord Perry p, 1962-1983 60
  22. Ken Keltner 3b, 1937-1950 59
  23. Elmer Flick rf, 1898-1910 59
  24. Jim Bagby p, 1912-1923 58
  25. Mike Garcia p, 1948-1961 57
  26. Manny Ramirez lf, 1993-2011 57
  27. George Uhle p, 1919-1936 56
  28. Willis Hudlin p, 1926-1944 54
  29. Hal Trosky 1b, 1933-1946 53
  30. Grady Sizemore cf, 2004-2015 53
  31. Luis Tiant p, 1964-1982 53
  32. Albert Belle lf, 1989-2000 53
  33. Bobby Avila 2b, 1949-1959 51
  34. Charles Nagy p, 1990-2003 50
  35. Ray Chapman ss, 1912-1920 49
  36. Jeff Heath lf, 1936-1949 48
  37. CC Sabathia p, 2001-2016 48
  38. Omar Vizquel ss, 1989-2012 47
  39. Vean Gregg p, 1911-1925 46
  40. Steve O'Neill c, 1911-1928 45
  41. Bert Blyleven p, 1970-1992 45
  42. Bartolo Colon p, 1997-2016 44
  43. Travis Hafner dh, 2002-2013 43
  44. Tom Candiotti p, 1983-1999 42
  45. Rocky Colavito rf, 1955-1968 42
  46. Roberto Alomar 2b, 1988-2004 41
  47. Sonny Siebert p, 1964-1975 41
  48. Joe Gordon 2b, 1938-1950 41
  49. Buddy Bell 3b, 1972-1989 40
  50. Shin-Soo Choo rf, 2005-2016 40
  51. Corey Kluber p, 2011-2016 38
  52. Johnny Allen p, 1932-1944 38
  53. Victor Martinez c, 2002-2016 37
  54. Carlos Santana c, 2010-2016 36
  55. Jason Kipnis 2b, 2011-2016 36
  56. Carlos Baerga 2b, 1990-2005 35
  57. Woodie Held ss, 1954-1969 34
  58. Graig Nettles 3b, 1967-1988 34
  59. Asdrubal Cabrera ss, 2007-2016 34
  60. Toby Harrah 3b, 1969-1986 33
  61. John Romano c, 1958-1967 32
  62. Charlie Jamieson lf, 1915-1932 32
  63. Brett Butler cf, 1981-1997 31
  64. Andre Thornton dh, 1973-1987 31
  65. Dale Mitchell lf, 1946-1956 31
  66. Guy Morton p, 1914-1924 31
  67. Jake Miller p, 1924-1933 31
  68. Herb Score p, 1955-1962 30
  69. Steve Gromek p, 1941-1957 30
  70. Greg Swindell p, 1986-2002 29
  71. Cliff Lee p, 2002-2014 29
  72. Michael Brantley cf, 2009-2016 28
  73. Ray Narleski p, 1954-1959 27
  74. Joe Vosmik lf, 1930-1944 26
  75. Dennis Martinez p, 1976-1998 26
  76. Dennis Eckersley p, 1975-1998 26
  77. Sandy Alomar c, 1988-2007 25
  78. Joe Shaute p, 1922-1934 25
  79. Steve Hargan p, 1965-1977 25
  80. Brook Jacoby 3b, 1981-1992 25
  81. Odell Hale 2b, 1931-1941 24
  82. Ed Morgan 1b, 1928-1934 24
  83. Julio Franco ss, 1982-2007 24
  84. Carlos Carrasco p, 2009-2016 24
  85. Eric Plunk p, 1986-1999 24
  86. Doug Jones p, 1982-2000 23
  87. Joe Azcue c, 1960-1972 23
  88. Sherry Smith p, 1911-1927 23
  89. Jhonny Peralta ss, 2003-2016 23
  90. Rick Waits p, 1973-1985 23
  91. Jose Mesa p, 1987-2007 23
  92. Clint Brown p, 1928-1942 22
  93. Willie Mitchell p, 1909-1919 22
  94. Ray Fosse c, 1967-1979 22
  95. Casey Blake 3b, 1999-2011 22
  96. Oral Hildebrand p, 1931-1940 22
  97. Gary Bell p, 1958-1969 22
  98. Bill Bernhard p, 1899-1907 22
  99. Joe Carter lf, 1983-1998 21
  100. Tito Francona lf, 1956-1970 21
  101. Minnie Miñoso lf, 1949-1980 21
  102. Mike Hargrove 1b, 1974-1985 21
  103. Larry Gardner 3b, 1908-1924 21
  104. Earl Moore p, 1901-1914 21
  105. Harry Bemis c, 1902-1910 21
  106. Francisco Lindor ss, 2015-2016 21
  107. Cy Falkenberg p, 1903-1917 21
  108. George Burns 1b, 1914-1929 20
  109. Don Mossi p, 1954-1965 20
  110. Nig Clarke c, 1905-1920 20
  111. Yan Gomes 1b, 2012-2016 19
  112. Jake Westbrook p, 2000-2013 19
  113. Dan Spillner p, 1974-1985 19
  114. Charlie Hickman 1b, 1897-1908 19
  115. Dave Burba p, 1990-2004 19
  116. Jim Piersall cf, 1950-1967 19
  117. Al Smith rf, 1953-1964 18
  118. Bob Rhoads p, 1902-1909 18
  119. Les Fleming 1b, 1939-1949 18
  120. Len Barker p, 1976-1987 18
  121. Rafael Betancourt p, 2003-2015 18
  122. Sid Monge p, 1975-1984 17
  123. Duke Sims c, 1964-1974 17
  124. Johnny Hodapp 2b, 1925-1933 17
  125. Roy Cullenbine rf, 1938-1947 17
  126. Braggo Roth rf, 1914-1921 17
  127. Frank Duffy ss, 1970-1979 17
  128. David Justice rf, 1989-2002 17
  129. Jim Perry p, 1959-1975 17
  130. Paul Shuey p, 1994-2007 17
  131. Rick Sutcliffe p, 1976-1994 17
  132. Rick Manning cf, 1975-1987 16
  133. George Stovall 1b, 1904-1915 16
  134. Luke Easter 1b, 1949-1954 16
  135. Fred Blanding p, 1910-1914 16
  136. Garland Buckeye p, 1918-1928 16
  137. Cody Allen p, 2012-2016 16
  138. Ron Hassey c, 1978-1991 15
  139. Lew Fonseca 1b, 1921-1933 15
  140. Harry Bay cf, 1901-1908 15
  141. Ronnie Belliard 2b, 1998-2010 15
  142. Steve Karsay p, 1993-2006 15
  143. Elmer Smith rf, 1914-1925 15
  144. Vic Davalillo cf, 1963-1980 15
  145. Coco Crisp cf, 2002-2016 15
  146. John Farrell p, 1987-1996 15
  147. Monte Pearson p, 1932-1941 14
  148. Riggs Stephenson lf, 1921-1934 14
  149. Orel Hershiser p, 1983-2000 14
  150. Danny Salazar p, 2013-2016 14
  151. Frankie Pytlak c, 1932-1946 14
  152. Jim Kern p, 1974-1986 14
  153. Jack Graney lf, 1908-1922 14
  154. Jack Kralick p, 1959-1967 14
  155. Glenn Myatt c, 1920-1936 14
  156. Ray Boone 3b, 1948-1960 14
  157. Lloyd Brown p, 1925-1940 14
  158. Brian Giles rf, 1995-2009 14
  159. Al Benton p, 1934-1952 14
  160. Cal McLish p, 1944-1964 13
  161. Stan Williams p, 1958-1972 13
  162. Joe Smith p, 2007-2016 13
  163. Michael Jackson p, 1986-2004 13
  164. Justin Masterson p, 2008-2015 13
  165. Bill Steen p, 1912-1915 13
  166. Roberto Hernandez p, 2006-2016 13
  167. Hank Edwards rf, 1941-1953 13
  168. Kelly Shoppach c, 2005-2013 13
  169. Joe Harris 1b, 1914-1928 13
  170. Bruce Campbell rf, 1930-1942 12
  171. Buddy Black p, 1981-1995 12
  172. Ellis Burks cf, 1987-2004 12
  173. Bob Wickman p, 1992-2007 12
  174. Travis Fryman 3b, 1990-2002 12
  175. Dave LaRoche p, 1970-1983 12
  176. Fritz Coumbe p, 1914-1921 12
  177. David Riske p, 1999-2010 12
  178. Max Alvis 3b, 1962-1970 12
  179. Ted Easterly c, 1909-1915 12
  180. Willie Kamm 3b, 1923-1935 12
  181. Derek Lilliquist p, 1989-1996 11
  182. Vic Power 1b, 1954-1965 11
  183. Al Smith p, 1934-1945 11
  184. Jose Ramirez 2b, 2013-2016 11
  185. Rico Carty lf, 1963-1979 11
  186. Jim Bibby p, 1972-1984 11
  187. George Strickland ss, 1950-1960 11
  188. John Denny p, 1974-1986 11
  189. Chad Ogea p, 1994-1999 11
  190. Joe Heving p, 1930-1945 11
  191. Tony Horton 1b, 1964-1970 11
  192. Denny Galehouse p, 1934-1949 11
  193. Oscar Gamble rf, 1969-1985 10
  194. Bryan Shaw p, 2011-2016 10
  195. George Hendrick rf, 1971-1988 10
  196. Gene Woodling lf, 1943-1962 10
  197. Vic Wertz rf, 1947-1963 10
  198. Rafael Perez p, 2006-2012 10
  199. Chuck Finley p, 1986-2002 10
  200. Vinnie Pestano p, 2010-2015 10

Greatest Cleveland Indians by Hall Rating

Nap Lajoie Photo
  1. Nap Lajoie
  2. Tris Speaker
  3. Lou Boudreau
  4. Bob Feller
  5. Stan Coveleski

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the Cleveland Indians (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: Steve O'Neill (45)
  2. 1B: Jim Thome (94)
  3. 2B: Nap Lajoie (172)
  4. 3B: Bill Bradley (68)
  5. SS: Lou Boudreau (130)
  6. LF: Joe Jackson (74)
  7. CF: Tris Speaker (156)
  8. RF: Elmer Flick (59)
  9. P: Bob Feller (130)

Bench

  1. CF: Kenny Lofton (97)
  2. CF: Larry Doby (90)
  3. CF: Earl Averill (88)
  4. SS: Joe Sewell (80)
  5. 3B: Al Rosen (66)
  6. SS: Terry Turner (62)
  7. 3B: Ken Keltner (59)

Bullpen

  1. P: Stan Coveleski (107)
  2. P: Sam McDowell (86)
  3. P: Addie Joss (85)
  4. P: Mel Harder (85)
  5. P: Bob Lemon (76)
  6. P: Early Wynn (74)
  7. P: Wes Ferrell (66)
  8. P: Gaylord Perry (60)
  9. P: Jim Bagby (58)