Cincinnati Kelly’s Killers (1891)

23 Greatest Cincinnati Kelly’s Killers

  1. Ed Crane p, 1884-1893 7
  2. Willard Mains p, 1888-1896 6
  3. Emmett Seery lf, 1884-1892 5
  4. King Kelly rf, 1878-1893 5
  5. Frank Dwyer p, 1888-1899 1
  6. John Carney 1b, 1889-1891 1
  7. Charlie Bell p, 1889-1891 0
  8. John Slagle p, 1891 0
  9. Farmer Vaughn c, 1886-1899 0
  10. Billy Clingman 3b, 1890-1903 0
  11. Jerry Hurley c, 1889-1891 0
  12. Joe Burke 3b, 1890-1891 0
  13. Wild Bill Widner p, 1887-1891 0
  14. Jack Keenan p, 1891 0
  15. Charlie Bastian ss, 1884-1891 0
  16. Willie McGill p, 1890-1896 0
  17. Matt Kilroy p, 1886-1898 0
  18. Lefty Marr rf, 1886-1891 0
  19. Jim Canavan lf, 1891-1897 -1
  20. Art Whitney 3b, 1880-1891 -1
  21. Ed Andrews cf, 1884-1891 -1
  22. Yank Robinson 2b, 1882-1892 -1
  23. Dick Johnston cf, 1884-1891 -2

Greatest Cincinnati Kelly’s Killers by Hall Rating

  1. Ed Crane
  2. Willard Mains
  3. Emmett Seery
  4. King Kelly
  5. Frank Dwyer

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the Cincinnati Kelly’s Killers (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: Farmer Vaughn (0)
  2. 1B: John Carney (1)
  3. 2B: Yank Robinson (-1)
  4. 3B: Billy Clingman (0)
  5. SS: Charlie Bastian (0)
  6. LF: Emmett Seery (5)
  7. CF: Ed Andrews (-1)
  8. RF: King Kelly (5)
  9. P: Ed Crane (7)

Bench

  1. C: Jerry Hurley (0)
  2. 3B: Joe Burke (0)
  3. RF: Lefty Marr (0)
  4. LF: Jim Canavan (-1)
  5. 3B: Art Whitney (-1)
  6. CF: Dick Johnston (-2)

Bullpen

  1. P: Willard Mains (6)
  2. P: Frank Dwyer (1)
  3. P: Charlie Bell (0)
  4. P: John Slagle (0)
  5. P: Wild Bill Widner (0)
  6. P: Jack Keenan (0)
  7. P: Willie McGill (0)
  8. P: Matt Kilroy (0)