Brooklyn Gladiators (1890)

22 Greatest Brooklyn Gladiators

  1. Jumbo Davis 3b, 1884-1891 2
  2. Candy Nelson ss, 1872-1890 2
  3. Billy O'Brien 1b, 1884-1890 1
  4. Steve Toole p, 1886-1890 1
  5. Ed Daily rf, 1885-1891 1
  6. Frank Fennelly ss, 1884-1890 1
  7. Hank Simon lf, 1887-1890 1
  8. Peter Connell 3b, 1886-1890 0
  9. Jack Lynch p, 1881-1890 0
  10. Hi Church lf, 1890 0
  11. Gus Williams p, 1890 0
  12. Jim Powers p, 1890 0
  13. Joe Gerhardt 2b, 1873-1891 0
  14. Fred Siefke 3b, 1890 -1
  15. Herman Pitz c, 1890 -1
  16. John Peltz cf, 1884-1890 -1
  17. Jim Toy 1b, 1887-1890 -1
  18. Bob Murphy p, 1890 -1
  19. Tom Ford p, 1890 -2
  20. Frank Bowes c, 1890 -2
  21. Mike Mattimore p, 1887-1890 -2
  22. Charlie McCullough p, 1890 -2

Greatest Brooklyn Gladiators by Hall Rating

  1. Jumbo Davis
  2. Candy Nelson
  3. Billy O'Brien
  4. Steve Toole
  5. Ed Daily

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the Brooklyn Gladiators (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: Herman Pitz (-1)
  2. 1B: Billy O'Brien (1)
  3. 2B: Joe Gerhardt (0)
  4. 3B: Jumbo Davis (2)
  5. SS: Candy Nelson (2)
  6. LF: Hank Simon (1)
  7. CF: John Peltz (-1)
  8. RF: Ed Daily (1)
  9. P: Steve Toole (1)

Bench

  1. SS: Frank Fennelly (1)
  2. 3B: Peter Connell (0)
  3. LF: Hi Church (0)
  4. 3B: Fred Siefke (-1)
  5. 1B: Jim Toy (-1)
  6. C: Frank Bowes (-2)

Bullpen

  1. P: Jack Lynch (0)
  2. P: Gus Williams (0)
  3. P: Jim Powers (0)
  4. P: Bob Murphy (-1)
  5. P: Tom Ford (-2)
  6. P: Mike Mattimore (-2)
  7. P: Charlie McCullough (-2)