When Did They Become Hall-Worthy?

Jun 17, 2013 by Adam Darowski

Babe Ruth’s Hall Rating of 400 is fun to look at. It basically means that he packed four Hall of Fame careers into one. So, at what point in his career did he actually become Hall-worthy?

We can answer this by seeing when he passed a Hall Rating of 100. He did that in 1920, his first season in New York. That was his age 25 season. Yikes.

In Albert Pujols’s younger days, people used to ask all the time, “if he got hurt today and could never play again, would he be a Hall of Famer?” According to the Hall of Stats, the answer to that question changed from “No” to “Yes” at the very end of 2006. He was 26.

Let’s look at the top 50 players by Hall Rating and see when they cleared the 100 mark.

Name Hall Rating Hall-worthy Year Hall-worthy Age
Ty Cobb 319 1911 24
Babe Ruth 400 1920 25
Walter Johnson 337 1913 25
Rogers Hornsby 290 1921 25
Mickey Mantle 238 1957 25
Kid Nichols 230 1895 25
Tris Speaker 281 1914 26
Alex Rodriguez 241 2002 26
Mel Ott 227 1935 26
Jimmie Foxx 207 1934 26
Albert Pujols 199 2006 26
Johnny Bench 181 1974 26
Ken Griffey 172 1996 26
Barry Bonds 363 1992 27
Willie Mays 336 1958 27
Hank Aaron 296 1961 27
Ted Williams 280 1946 27
Stan Musial 264 1948 27
Eddie Collins 254 1914 27
Lou Gehrig 241 1930 27
Rickey Henderson 231 1986 27
Frank Robinson 212 1963 27
Christy Mathewson 209 1908 27
Eddie Mathews 191 1959 27
Bert Blyleven 190 1978 27
Al Kaline 187 1962 27
Cy Young 336 1895 28
Roger Clemens 293 1991 28
Tom Seaver 220 1973 28
Cal Ripken 187 1989 28
Pedro Martinez 187 2000 28
Carl Yastrzemski 184 1968 28
George Brett 179 1981 28
Pete Alexander 251 1916 29
Nap Lajoie 228 1904 29
Mike Schmidt 227 1979 29
Greg Maddux 220 1995 29
Honus Wagner 283 1904 30
Joe Morgan 203 1974 30
Roger Connor 185 1888 30
Wade Boggs 185 1988 30
Dan Brouthers 180 1888 30
Lefty Grove 233 1932 32
Cap Anson 215 1884 32
Roberto Clemente 190 1967 32
Warren Spahn 176 1954 33
Gaylord Perry 173 1973 34
Curt Schilling 172 2001 34
Randy Johnson 219 1999 35
Phil Niekro 188 1976 37

Hall-worthy at age…

24

The only player from the Top 50 who became Hall-worthy at a younger age than Ruth is Ty Cobb. In 1911, Cobb had a monster season, leading the league in batting average, slugging, OPS, OPS+, total bases, runs, runs batted in, doubles, and triples. He also led the league in WAR with 10.7. For comparison’s sake, Mike Trout was worth 10.9 WAR last year.

25

Ruth is joined by Rogers Hornsby and Mickey Mantle, as well as a couple pitchers in Walter Johnson and Kid Nichols. The “worst” career ranking for any of these players is 21st all time (Nichols).

26

Pujols isn’t the only super-modern player in this group as he is joined by Ken Griffey and Alex Rodriguez. A-Rod just missed the age 25 group, finishing 2001 with a 99.98 Hall Rating.

Tris Speaker, Mel Ott, Jimmie Foxx, and Johnny Bench round out the Age 26 group. Ott became a full-time player at age 19 while Speaker’s first full season was at age 21. Foxx and Bench were full-timers at 20.

27

Age 27 is the oft-accepted peak age for hitters. It seems to be supported here, as well. All players on this list have a Hall Rating of at least 172. That puts 100 relatively close to the middle of the career for a good percentage of the list. And we do indeed see our largest list of players here.

Barry Bonds, Willie Mays, Hank Aaron, Ted Williams, Stan Musial, and Eddie Collins all had Hall Ratings of 250 or better. Bonds actually became a Hall of Famer while still with Pittsburgh, so everything he did with the Giants was just icing on the cake.

And that’s a lot of icing.

Mays missed most of two seasons to war while Stan Musial missed a season as well. Ted Williams, of course, missed four seasons, reaching Hall-worthiness in 1946, his first year back from World War II.

Lou Gehrig, Rickey Henderson, Frank Robinson, and Christy Mathewson all had Hall Ratings of 200 or better. Eddie Mathews and Al Kaline are all time greats, though you don’t hear them discussed nearly as often as the others.

Then there’s Bert Blyleven, here to make the non-stat geeks cringe. Yup, Blyleven was Hall-worthy in 1978. Thirty-four years later, he was finally inducted.

28

We start this list with three of the greatest pitchers of all time—Cy Young, Roger Clemens, and Tom Seaver. One might also add Pedro Martinez (as I would).

Cal Ripken, Carl Yastrzemski, and George Brett all had very long playing careers and accumulated massive totals—even after being Hall-worthy at the relatively young age of 28.

29

Pete Alexander, Nap Lajoie, Mike Schmidt, and Greg Maddux all had long, relatively consistent careers. They didn’t have individual seasons quite like Ruth or Mays (usually), but they just had great numbers, year after year.

30

Honus Wagner surprised me a bit. He was incredibly valuable in his 30s, though. He ended up with a 283 Hall Rating—a full 80 points ahead of Joe Morgan (who I always considered a bit of a late-blooming All Time Great). Wade Boggs, of course, was blocked at third base early in his career, but more than made up for it. Roger Connor and Dan Brouthers are 19th Century stars, so it makes sense that they reached Hall-worthiness later (as the season schedules began to expand).

32

Lefty Grove received his late start after winning 108 games for the famous minor league Baltimore Orioles—all by the age of 24. Then he was finally sold to the A’s and started his big league career. Cap Anson, like Connor and Brouthers, was slowed by short seasons. Both just missed being Hall-worthy in their age 31 season. Grove finished 1931 with a Hall Rating of 99.967989 (sorry, but it’s not quite 100!) while Anson finished 1883 with 99.5559.

Roberto Clemente’s WAR totals from age 30 to 34 were 7.1, 8.2, 8.9, 8.1, and 7.5. He was a defensive force in the first half of his career. His offense caught up in the second half.

33

Warren Spahn got his start later because he missed three year very early in his career to World War II. I’m not sure I even knew that until now.

34

Gaylord Perry and Curt Schilling were both very effective pitchers later in their careers. Schilling’s Hall-worthiness came during his magical 2001 season with the Diamondbacks.

35

It took Randy Johnson many years to harness his extraordinary arsenal. He became Hall-worthy in Arizona as well. In fact, it was during his first season there.

37

Phil Niekro is the oldest player on the list. He reached a 100 Hall Rating at age 37, yet still finished with a Hall Rating of 188. Amazing.

Worth Noting

Just remember, this is not a list of the youngest ages that a player reached Hall-worthiness. Sandy Koufax, for example, reached his 100 Hall Rating at age 30. But he did it in his final season, so he didn’t make the list of the top 50 players of all time. Likewise, Miguel Cabrera will be reaching Hall-worthiness this season. He’s also 30.

comments powered by Disqus

Latest Articles RSS