Hall of Stats
Menu
They say, “It’s the Hall of Fame, not the Hall of Stats.”
But what if it were?
The Hall of Stats shows us what the Hall of Fame would look like if we removed all 211 inductees and replaced them with the top 211 eligible players in history, according to a mathematical formula. (more)
211 Hall of Stats Inductees
- Babe Ruth rf, 1914-1935 395
- Barry Bonds lf, 1986-2007 359
- Walter Johnson p, 1907-1927 333
- Willie Mays cf, 1951-1973 332
- Cy Young p, 1890-1911 332
- Ty Cobb cf, 1905-1928 315
- Hank Aaron rf, 1954-1976 293
- Roger Clemens p, 1984-2007 290
- Rogers Hornsby 2b, 1915-1937 286
- Honus Wagner ss, 1897-1917 280
- Tris Speaker cf, 1907-1928 277
- Ted Williams lf, 1939-1960 276
- Stan Musial lf, 1941-1963 261
- Eddie Collins 2b, 1906-1930 251
- Pete Alexander p, 1911-1930 248
- Alex Rodriguez ss, 1994-2013 239
- Lou Gehrig 1b, 1923-1939 239
- Mickey Mantle cf, 1951-1968 235
- Lefty Grove p, 1925-1941 230
- Rickey Henderson lf, 1979-2003 228
- Kid Nichols p, 1890-1906 227
- Nap Lajoie 2b, 1896-1916 225
- Mike Schmidt 3b, 1972-1989 225
- Mel Ott rf, 1926-1947 224
- Tom Seaver p, 1967-1986 217
- Greg Maddux p, 1986-2008 217
- Randy Johnson p, 1988-2009 216
- Cap Anson 1b, 1871-1897 212
- Frank Robinson rf, 1956-1976 209
- Christy Mathewson p, 1900-1916 207
- Jimmie Foxx 1b, 1925-1945 204
- Joe Morgan 2b, 1963-1984 200
- Albert Pujols 1b, 2001-2013 198
- Eddie Mathews 3b, 1952-1968 189
- Bert Blyleven p, 1970-1992 188
- Roberto Clemente rf, 1955-1972 187
- Phil Niekro p, 1964-1987 186
- Cal Ripken ss, 1981-2001 185
- Pedro Martinez p, 1992-2009 185
- Al Kaline rf, 1953-1974 185
- Roger Connor 1b, 1880-1897 183
- Wade Boggs 3b, 1982-1999 183
- Carl Yastrzemski lf, 1961-1983 182
- Johnny Bench c, 1967-1983 179
- Dan Brouthers 1b, 1879-1904 178
- George Brett 3b, 1973-1993 177
- Warren Spahn p, 1942-1965 174
- Gaylord Perry p, 1962-1983 171
- Ken Griffey cf, 1989-2010 170
- Curt Schilling p, 1988-2007 170
- Bob Gibson p, 1959-1975 168
- Chipper Jones 3b, 1993-2012 168
- Eddie Plank p, 1901-1917 167
- Joe DiMaggio cf, 1936-1951 166
- George Davis ss, 1890-1909 166
- Steve Carlton p, 1965-1988 165
- Gary Carter c, 1974-1992 164
- Jeff Bagwell 1b, 1991-2005 162
- Mike Mussina p, 1991-2008 161
- Charlie Gehringer 2b, 1924-1942 157
- Carlton Fisk c, 1969-1993 156
- Rod Carew 1b, 1967-1985 156
- Fergie Jenkins p, 1965-1983 155
- Robin Roberts p, 1948-1966 154
- Ivan Rodriguez c, 1991-2011 152
- Larry Walker rf, 1989-2005 149
- Pete Rose lf, 1963-1986 148
- Arky Vaughan ss, 1932-1948 148
- Ed Delahanty lf, 1888-1903 147
- Tom Glavine p, 1987-2008 147
- Brooks Robinson 3b, 1955-1977 147
- Mike Piazza c, 1992-2007 145
- Ozzie Smith ss, 1978-1996 145
- Nolan Ryan p, 1966-1993 144
- Luke Appling ss, 1930-1950 144
- Reggie Jackson rf, 1967-1987 144
- Bill Dahlen ss, 1891-1911 143
- Johnny Mize 1b, 1936-1953 143
- Bobby Wallace ss, 1894-1918 143
- Lou Whitaker 2b, 1977-1995 142
- Robin Yount ss, 1974-1993 142
- Barry Larkin ss, 1986-2004 142
- Alan Trammell ss, 1977-1996 141
- Scott Rolen 3b, 1996-2012 140
- Bobby Grich 2b, 1970-1986 139
- Paul Molitor dh, 1978-1998 139
- Frank Thomas dh, 1990-2008 138
- Ron Santo 3b, 1960-1974 138
- Paul Waner rf, 1926-1945 137
- Tim Keefe p, 1880-1893 137
- Roy Halladay p, 1998-2013 137
- Kevin Brown p, 1986-2005 137
- Frankie Frisch 2b, 1919-1937 136
- Harry Heilmann rf, 1914-1932 136
- Jim Thome 1b, 1991-2012 135
- John Smoltz p, 1988-2009 135
- Rick Reuschel p, 1972-1991 135
- Carl Hubbell p, 1928-1943 135
- Yogi Berra c, 1946-1965 134
- Edgar Martinez dh, 1987-2004 133
- Adrian Beltre 3b, 1998-2013 133
- Sam Crawford rf, 1899-1917 133
- Ed Walsh p, 1904-1917 131
- Lou Boudreau ss, 1938-1952 131
- Kenny Lofton cf, 1991-2007 130
- John Clarkson p, 1882-1894 130
- Al Simmons lf, 1924-1944 130
- Mariano Rivera p, 1995-2013 130
- Billy Hamilton cf, 1888-1901 130
- Jack Glasscock ss, 1879-1895 129
- Carlos Beltran cf, 1998-2013 129
- Duke Snider cf, 1947-1964 129
- Joe Jackson lf, 1908-1920 128
- Luis Tiant p, 1964-1982 128
- Bob Feller p, 1936-1956 128
- Ryne Sandberg 2b, 1981-1997 128
- Manny Ramirez lf, 1993-2011 128
- David Cone p, 1986-2003 127
- Fred Clarke lf, 1894-1915 127
- Bill Dickey c, 1928-1946 127
- Dazzy Vance p, 1915-1935 127
- Ernie Banks 1b, 1953-1971 127
- Hal Newhouser p, 1939-1955 126
- Tim Raines lf, 1979-2002 126
- Derek Jeter ss, 1995-2013 126
- Tony Gwynn rf, 1982-2001 126
- Jim Palmer p, 1965-1984 126
- Willie McCovey 1b, 1959-1980 125
- Ted Lyons p, 1923-1946 125
- Joe Cronin ss, 1926-1945 125
- Andruw Jones cf, 1996-2012 125
- Craig Biggio 2b, 1988-2007 125
- Graig Nettles 3b, 1967-1988 125
- Roberto Alomar 2b, 1988-2004 124
- Amos Rusie p, 1889-1901 124
- Jackie Robinson 2b, 1947-1956 124
- Rafael Palmeiro 1b, 1986-2005 124
- Reggie Smith rf, 1966-1982 124
- Vic Willis p, 1898-1910 123
- Chase Utley 2b, 2003-2013 123
- Mark McGwire 1b, 1986-2001 123
- Dennis Eckersley p, 1975-1998 123
- Stan Coveleski p, 1912-1928 123
- Eddie Murray 1b, 1977-1997 123
- Willie Randolph 2b, 1975-1992 122
- Buddy Bell 3b, 1972-1989 122
- Dwight Evans rf, 1972-1991 122
- Home Run Baker 3b, 1908-1922 122
- Andre Dawson rf, 1976-1996 121
- Bret Saberhagen p, 1984-2001 120
- Gabby Hartnett c, 1922-1941 120
- Jim Edmonds cf, 1993-2010 120
- Todd Helton 1b, 1997-2013 119
- Pee Wee Reese ss, 1940-1958 119
- Mickey Cochrane c, 1925-1937 118
- Red Faber p, 1914-1933 118
- Jim Bunning p, 1955-1971 118
- Rube Waddell p, 1897-1910 117
- Hank Greenberg 1b, 1930-1947 117
- Richie Ashburn cf, 1948-1962 117
- Joe Gordon 2b, 1938-1950 116
- Goose Goslin lf, 1921-1938 116
- Ken Boyer 3b, 1955-1969 116
- Sal Bando 3b, 1966-1981 116
- Sammy Sosa rf, 1989-2007 115
- Dick Allen 1b, 1963-1977 115
- Gary Sheffield rf, 1988-2009 115
- Buck Ewing c, 1880-1897 114
- Juan Marichal p, 1960-1975 114
- Dave Stieb p, 1979-1998 114
- Keith Hernandez 1b, 1974-1990 114
- Mordecai Brown p, 1903-1916 113
- Clark Griffith p, 1891-1914 113
- Don Drysdale p, 1956-1969 113
- Old Hoss Radbourn p, 1880-1891 113
- Dave Winfield rf, 1973-1995 113
- Deacon White 3b, 1871-1890 113
- Jesse Burkett lf, 1890-1905 112
- Ted Simmons c, 1968-1988 112
- Harmon Killebrew 1b, 1954-1975 111
- Joe McGinnity p, 1899-1908 111
- Don Sutton p, 1966-1988 111
- Kevin Appier p, 1989-2004 111
- Joe Torre c, 1960-1977 111
- George Sisler 1b, 1915-1930 110
- Billy Williams lf, 1959-1976 110
- Vladimir Guerrero rf, 1996-2011 110
- Wes Ferrell p, 1927-1941 110
- Sherry Magee lf, 1904-1919 110
- Jake Beckley 1b, 1888-1907 109
- Bobby Bonds rf, 1968-1981 109
- Bobby Abreu rf, 1996-2012 109
- Eddie Cicotte p, 1905-1920 109
- Jim Wynn cf, 1963-1977 109
- Urban Shocker p, 1916-1928 108
- Jack Quinn p, 1909-1933 108
- Chet Lemon cf, 1975-1990 108
- Andy Pettitte p, 1995-2013 108
- Pud Galvin p, 1875-1892 108
- Chuck Finley p, 1986-2002 108
- Babe Adams p, 1906-1926 107
- Hoyt Wilhelm p, 1952-1972 107
- Zack Wheat lf, 1909-1927 106
- Johan Santana p, 2000-2012 106
- Bill Terry 1b, 1923-1936 106
- Bob Johnson lf, 1933-1945 106
- Ichiro Suzuki rf, 2001-2013 105
- Jim O'Rourke lf, 1872-1904 105
- Tim Hudson p, 1999-2013 105
- Darrell Evans 3b, 1969-1989 105
- Early Wynn p, 1939-1963 105
- Tommy John p, 1963-1989 105
- Whitey Ford p, 1950-1967 104
- Tony Mullane p, 1881-1894 104
- Roy Oswalt p, 2001-2013 104
- Red Ruffing p, 1924-1947 103
- Miguel Cabrera 3b, 2003-2013 103
- Jim McCormick p, 1878-1887 103
- Gene Tenace c, 1969-1983 103
- Joe Medwick lf, 1932-1948 103
- Elmer Flick rf, 1898-1910 103
- Willie Stargell lf, 1962-1982 103
- Willie Davis cf, 1960-1979 103
- Joe Tinker ss, 1902-1916 102
- Tommy Bond p, 1874-1884 102
- Jeff Kent 2b, 1992-2008 102
- John Olerud 1b, 1989-2005 102
- Will Clark 1b, 1986-2000 101
- Charlie Bennett c, 1878-1893 101
- Robin Ventura 3b, 1989-2004 101
- CC Sabathia p, 2001-2013 101
- Charlie Buffinton p, 1882-1892 101
- King Kelly rf, 1878-1893 101
- Orel Hershiser p, 1983-2000 101
- Larry Doby cf, 1947-1959 101
- Wilbur Wood p, 1961-1978 101
- Jimmy Collins 3b, 1895-1908 100
- César Cedeño cf, 1970-1986 100
- Sandy Koufax p, 1955-1966 100
- Thurman Munson c, 1969-1979 100
- Billy Pierce p, 1945-1964 100
- Nap Rucker p, 1907-1916 99
- Frank Tanana p, 1973-1993 99
- Joe Mauer c, 2004-2013 99
- Ernie Lombardi c, 1931-1947 99
- Minnie Miñoso lf, 1949-1980 99
- Eppa Rixey p, 1912-1933 99
- Jerry Koosman p, 1967-1985 99
- Lance Berkman lf, 1999-2013 98
- David Wells p, 1987-2007 98
- Wilbur Cooper p, 1912-1926 98
- Eddie Rommel p, 1920-1932 98
- Bid McPhee 2b, 1882-1899 98
- Joe Kelley lf, 1891-1908 98
- Billy Herman 2b, 1931-1947 97
- Ron Cey 3b, 1971-1987 97
- Willie Keeler rf, 1892-1910 97
- Tommy Bridges p, 1930-1946 97
- Bobby Doerr 2b, 1937-1951 97
- Jose Cruz lf, 1970-1988 97
- Brian Giles rf, 1995-2009 97
- John McGraw 3b, 1891-1906 97
- Ted Breitenstein p, 1891-1901 96
- Harry Stovey lf, 1880-1893 96
- Burleigh Grimes p, 1916-1934 96
- Mark Buehrle p, 2000-2013 96
- Hippo Vaughn p, 1908-1921 96
- Dizzy Trout p, 1939-1957 95
- Kenny Rogers p, 1989-2008 95
- Paul Hines cf, 1872-1891 95
- Art Fletcher ss, 1909-1922 95
- Bert Campaneris ss, 1964-1983 95
- Bob Caruthers p, 1884-1893 95
- Tony Perez 1b, 1964-1986 95
- Jack Clark rf, 1975-1992 94
- Mark Langston p, 1984-1999 94
- Fred McGriff 1b, 1986-2004 94
- Max Carey cf, 1910-1929 94
- Enos Slaughter rf, 1938-1959 94
- Jimmy Key p, 1984-1998 94
- Wally Schang c, 1913-1931 94
- Luis Aparicio ss, 1956-1973 93
- Waite Hoyt p, 1918-1938 93
- Jack Powell p, 1897-1912 93
- Jason Giambi 1b, 1995-2013 93
- Frank Chance 1b, 1898-1914 93
- Norm Cash 1b, 1958-1974 93
- Monte Ward ss, 1878-1894 93
- Fred Lynn cf, 1974-1990 93
- Heinie Groh 3b, 1912-1927 93
- Dennis Martinez p, 1976-1998 93
- Bill Freehan c, 1961-1976 93
- Noodles Hahn p, 1899-1906 93
- Dave Bancroft ss, 1915-1930 93
- Roger Bresnahan c, 1897-1915 92
- Stan Hack 3b, 1932-1947 92
- Ron Guidry p, 1975-1988 92
- Bernie Williams cf, 1991-2006 92
- Kirby Puckett cf, 1984-1995 92
- Dwight Gooden p, 1984-2000 92
- Bobo Newsom p, 1929-1953 92
- Ralph Kiner lf, 1946-1955 92
- Bucky Walters p, 1931-1950 92
- Pete Browning lf, 1882-1894 92
- Jim Fregosi ss, 1961-1978 92
- Al Spalding p, 1871-1878 92
- Dizzy Dean p, 1930-1947 92
- Brian Downing dh, 1973-1992 92
- David Wright 3b, 2004-2013 91
- Vada Pinson cf, 1958-1975 91
- Joe Sewell ss, 1920-1933 91
- Toby Harrah 3b, 1969-1986 90
- Dutch Leonard p, 1933-1953 90
- Chief Bender p, 1903-1925 90
- Charlie Keller lf, 1939-1952 90
- Mickey Welch p, 1880-1892 90
- Nomar Garciaparra ss, 1996-2009 90
- Johnny Damon cf, 1995-2012 89
- Jorge Posada c, 1995-2011 89
- Rich Gossage p, 1972-1994 89
- Nellie Fox 2b, 1947-1965 89
- Jamie Moyer p, 1986-2012 88
- Robinson Cano 2b, 2005-2013 88
- Johnny Evers 2b, 1902-1929 87
- Hughie Jennings ss, 1891-1918 87
- Earl Averill cf, 1929-1941 87
- Mark Teixeira 1b, 2003-2013 87
- Edd Roush cf, 1913-1931 87
- Tony Lazzeri 2b, 1926-1939 87
- Travis Jackson ss, 1922-1936 86
- J.D. Drew rf, 1998-2011 86
- Kiki Cuyler rf, 1921-1938 86
- Jason Kendall c, 1996-2010 86
- Cupid Childs 2b, 1888-1901 85
- Chuck Klein rf, 1928-1944 85
- Javier Vazquez p, 1998-2011 85
- Jimmy Sheckard lf, 1897-1913 85
- Cliff Lee p, 2002-2013 85
- Addie Joss p, 1902-1910 84
- Sam Thompson rf, 1885-1906 84
- Torii Hunter cf, 1997-2013 83
- Harry Hooper rf, 1909-1925 83
- Hardy Richardson 2b, 1879-1892 83
- Carlos Zambrano p, 2001-2012 83
- George Gore cf, 1879-1892 83
- Bartolo Colon p, 1997-2013 83
- Mike Cameron cf, 1995-2011 82
- Orlando Cepeda 1b, 1958-1974 82
- Jim Rice lf, 1974-1989 82
- Ross Barnes 2b, 1871-1881 82
- Sam Rice rf, 1915-1934 81
- Herb Pennock p, 1912-1934 80
- Miguel Tejada ss, 1997-2013 79
- Justin Verlander p, 2005-2013 78
- Heinie Manush lf, 1923-1939 77
- Roy Campanella c, 1948-1957 77
- Hugh Duffy lf, 1888-1906 76
- Phil Rizzuto ss, 1941-1956 76
- Hack Wilson cf, 1923-1934 76
- Lefty Gomez p, 1930-1943 76
- Dustin Pedroia 2b, 2006-2013 76
- David Ortiz dh, 1997-2013 75
- Matt Holliday lf, 2004-2013 75
- Bob Lemon p, 1941-1958 75
- Joe Start 1b, 1871-1886 75
- Carlos Delgado 1b, 1993-2009 75
- Jack Chesbro p, 1899-1909 74
- Earle Combs cf, 1924-1935 74
- Roger Maris rf, 1957-1968 72
- Smoky Joe Wood rf, 1908-1922 72
- Rabbit Maranville ss, 1912-1935 72
- Lou Brock lf, 1961-1979 71
- Ezra Sutton 3b, 1871-1888 71
- Tom Gordon p, 1988-2009 69
- Brandon Webb p, 2003-2009 68
- Omar Vizquel ss, 1989-2012 68
- Troy Glaus 3b, 1998-2010 68
- Derek Lowe p, 1997-2013 67
- George Kell 3b, 1943-1957 66
- Red Schoendienst 2b, 1945-1963 65
- Chris Carpenter p, 1997-2012 65
- Billy Wagner p, 1995-2010 65
- Magglio Ordonez rf, 1997-2011 65
- Rube Marquard p, 1908-1925 65
- Catfish Hunter p, 1965-1979 64
- Charley Jones lf, 1875-1888 63
- Trevor Hoffman p, 1993-2010 62
- Cal McVey 1b, 1871-1879 61
- Jim Bottomley 1b, 1922-1937 60
- Ross Youngs rf, 1917-1926 60
- Jason Schmidt p, 1995-2009 59
- Tim Wakefield p, 1992-2011 59
- Pie Traynor 3b, 1920-1937 59
- Jesse Haines p, 1918-1937 57
- Derrek Lee 1b, 1997-2011 57
- Chick Hafey lf, 1924-1937 56
- Kerry Wood p, 1998-2012 55
- Bruce Sutter p, 1976-1988 54
- Darin Erstad 1b, 1996-2009 53
- Rollie Fingers p, 1968-1985 53
- Grady Sizemore cf, 2004-2011 53
- Rick Ferrell c, 1929-1947 52
- Bill Mazeroski 2b, 1956-1972 51
- Ray Schalk c, 1912-1929 51
- Edgar Renteria ss, 1996-2011 51
- Freddie Lindstrom 3b, 1924-1936 50
- Kevin Millwood p, 1997-2012 49
- Jarrod Washburn p, 1998-2009 48
- Cliff Floyd lf, 1993-2009 47
- Melvin Mora 3b, 1999-2011 47
- Ben Sheets p, 2001-2012 47
- Kelvim Escobar p, 1997-2009 47
- Luis Castillo 2b, 1996-2010 47
- Carlos Guillen ss, 1998-2011 45
- Mike Hampton p, 1993-2010 45
- Ryan Dempster p, 1998-2013 44
- Randy Winn rf, 1998-2010 43
- George Kelly 1b, 1915-1932 41
- Jason Varitek c, 1997-2011 41
- Mike Lowell 3b, 1998-2010 40
- Lip Pike cf, 1871-1887 39
- Mark Grudzielanek 2b, 1995-2010 39
- Garret Anderson lf, 1994-2010 38
- Casey Blake 3b, 1999-2011 37
- Mike Sweeney dh, 1995-2010 37
- Doug Davis p, 1999-2011 37
- Troy Percival p, 1995-2009 37
- Craig Counsell 2b, 1995-2011 36
- Chan Ho Park p, 1994-2010 36
- Arthur Rhodes p, 1991-2011 36
- Dontrelle Willis p, 2003-2011 36
- Aaron Rowand cf, 2001-2011 35
- Rich Harden p, 2003-2011 35
- Lloyd Waner cf, 1927-1945 34
- Jermaine Dye rf, 1996-2009 34
- Mark Loretta 2b, 1995-2009 33
- Ronnie Belliard 2b, 1998-2010 33
- Milton Bradley cf, 2000-2011 31
- Orlando Cabrera ss, 1997-2011 30
- Michael Young ss, 2000-2013 30
- Brad Ausmus c, 1993-2010 30
- David Eckstein ss, 2001-2010 29
- Eddie Guardado p, 1993-2009 29
- David Weathers p, 1991-2009 29
- Rich Aurilia ss, 1995-2009 28
- Tommy McCarthy rf, 1884-1896 28
- B.J. Ryan p, 1999-2009 28
- Gil Meche p, 1999-2010 27
- Pat Burrell lf, 2000-2011 27
- Scot Shields p, 2001-2010 27
- Gregg Zaun c, 1995-2010 26
- Paul Byrd p, 1995-2009 26
- Eric Milton p, 1998-2009 26
- Joel Pineiro p, 2000-2011 25
- Gary Matthews cf, 1999-2010 25
- Bob Howry p, 1998-2010 25
- Dickey Pearce ss, 1871-1877 22
Latest Articles RSS
- Why the Hall of Stats Doesn't Adjust for League Quality (Across Generations) • Mar 4, 2014
- Roy Oswalt and the Incredibly Strict Hall of Fame Standard for Pitchers • Feb 12, 2014
- SABR Boston Chapter Meeting Presentation and Recap • Jan 29, 2014
- I'm Speaking at SABR's Boston Chapter Meeting on January 20 • Jan 13, 2014
- Reaching the BBWAA Standard, not just the Hall of Fame Standard • Jan 10, 2014
- Hall of Stats Inducts Five, Removes Two • Jan 9, 2014
- Ken Davidoff Has a Near-Perfect Hall of Fame Ballot (by Hall Rating) • Jan 8, 2014
- New Visual: Graham Womack’s Top 50 Players Not in the Hall of Fame • Jan 7, 2014
- Boston Herald’s Michael Silverman: Best Ballot So Far, by Hall Rating • Dec 30, 2013
- Vote: 50 Best Players Not in the Hall of Fame (2014 Edition) • Dec 6, 2013
- See All Articles